With the holiday buying binge looming, it’s a critical time for consumers with swollen credit card balances to stick to a plan for paying down their debt.

But choosing the best payoff strategy can be tricky. If the plan isn’t a good fit, people are more likely to give up on it, experts say.

“Paying off credit cards is an important step toward financial health ... but the right strategy depends on an individual’s financial habits, personality and motivation for paying balances,” said Mike Sullivan, spokesman for the Phoenix-based nonprofit credit counseling service Take Charge America.

Some 38 percent of U.S. households are carrying credit card debt, with balances averaging $16,140, according to Nerdwallet.com, which derived the figures from 2013 Federal Reserve statistics and other government data.

Advertise with us

To cut that burden, experts say there are simple methods that consumers can use to make the payoff pill seem more like a sweet-tasting chewable than a swig of castor oil.

The Snowball. Pick the credit card with the smallest balance and pay it off as quickly as possible, making only the minimum payments on other cards. When the first card is paid off, apply the same payment — on top of the minimum — to the next smallest balance. Although this strategy could result in paying more interest over time, it works best for people who need help building good financial habits and will be motivated by early successes, Mr. Sullivan said.

The Avalanche. Consumers attack the card with the highest interest rate first, paying the minimums on other cards. This tactic focuses on saving on interest charges. Since it may feel slower, it’s best for consumers with the stamina to stick to a long-term goal, Mr. Sullivan said.

The Middle. Slower than the snowball and less strategic than the avalanche, this strategy doesn’t prescribe how to pay off debt. Consumers simply pay down balances on all of their cards at the same time. This tactic is best for people who feel they need to make a dent in all of their cards.

The Balance Transfer. Zero percent balance transfer offers can be a way to pay off debt faster by saving on interest charges. The catch is that some offers only provide low rates for a short introductory period of a few months. And most charge a balance transfer fee of 2 percent to 4 percent that could offset any savings in interest. Be sure to read the terms carefully.

Advertise with us

Some consumers also may have luck getting their interest rate lowered simply by calling their card issuer and asking.

“[Card companies] may agree if you’ve had a stellar payment history with them,” said Jeanine Skowronski, reporter and editor with San Francisco-based Credit.com. “Be aware, you’ll probably have to pay the old rate on old purchases,” she said.

Once a payoff plan is in place, setting up automatic payments through a bank or credit card website is a good way to keep the plan on track, Mr. Sullivan said.

With the holidays coming up, consumers should try hard not to overspend and add to their debts, Ms. Skowronski said.

One way to dramatically cut a shopping list is to start a Secret Santa or grab bag gift exchange with relatives instead of buying everyone in the family a gift, she said. Also consider homemade gifts such as a tin of cookies or crocheted scarf.

Advertise with us

“If you explain that money is tight, your family should understand.”

For more tips on paying down debt, contact Take Charge America at 866-528-0588. For an agency in Pittsburgh, try Advantage Credit Counseling Service at 412-390-1300 or 866-699-2227.

Patricia Sabatini: psabatini@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3066.