When is 24 hours not 24 hours?
When it’s an algorithm.
For the last five years, Huntington Bank has boasted about being the only bank nationwide that gives customers a 24-hour grace period to get their accounts in the black before assessing any overdraft fees.
The protection “comes free with all Huntington consumer checking, savings and money market deposit accounts,” the Columbus, Ohio-based bank’s promotional materials state.
But a closer look at the program reveals a catch.
Huntington — the Pittsburgh region’s sixth largest retail bank — first assesses the risk of letting a customer overdraw an account by using an algorithm based on the customer’s account history.
If Huntington decides to let a customer’s particular check or automatic payment clear even though it causes a negative balance, the 24-hour grace period applies.
But if the bank decides to stop the transaction from going through, 24-hour grace doesn’t apply. The customer is immediately charged a $37.50 “return” fee. (The first return fee in any given year is $23.)
“Obviously, we can’t let everyone overdraw all of the time,” the bank says on its website.
In essence, the bank decides who is covered by 24-hour grace and who isn’t.
“We aren’t guaranteeing that we are paying all payments,” spokesman Bill Eiler explained this week.
“24-hour grace is a great feature when you overdraw your account,” he said. “The key is that 24-hour grace applies when you overdraw your account,” not when the bank stops the payment from going through.
He said the “vast majority” of overdrafts are allowed to go through and are covered by the grace period. (If the bank stops a debit card transaction or ATM withdrawal, there is no fee.)
Huntington bases its decision on an algorithm using a number of factors — chiefly how long a customer has been with the bank, the size of the transaction, the frequency of deposits and the customer’s overdraft history, Mr. Eiler said.
What about customers who may consider the marketing to be misleading, since the bank actually is deciding on a case-by-case basis who gets covered by the program?
Mr. Eiler said exceptions to the program are explained on the company’s website and in a pamphlet given to customers when they open an account.
“We do the best we can [to honor payments] based on the relationship with the customer,” he said. “The best way to prevent overdrafts is to make sure you have the funds in your account to cover the payment.”
Overdraft fees have been an important source of revenue for banks over the years, with the country’s three largest banks together collecting some $1.14 billion in overdraft fees in the first quarter this year, according to SNL Financial, based in Charlottesville, Va.
Overdraft charges also tend to draw the ire of customers, who say they often feel blindsided by murky rules.
Mr. Eiler said since the 24-hour grace program was launched in 2010, it “has cost us a lot of revenue in fees.”
But he said the shortfall has been more than made up for by attracting new customers.
“A huge factor in that is 24-hour grace,” he said.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.