2016 Scion iM and iA: A little something new.

Price: Starting at $18,460 for the iM hatchback or $15,700 for the iA sedan.

Marketer’s pitch: The iM is “A hatchback with room for adventure.” The iA is “Where style meets substance.”

Reality: One shows some real potential; one rides in the bargain bin.

Advertise with us

Something new: When I think of Scion, I think of the boxy xB and sporty tC, and letters that start lower case and end with capitals. I don’t usually think of the Yaris and a Mazda.

But those are pretty more or less what these all-new vehicles are. Still, one is much better than its alter ego, and one is not as good.

Both offer a new direction for the division that aims to draw young, hip drivers into the Toyota fold — something its been doing since the brand first appeared on the scene in 2003. Both vehicles will follow in the direction many car companies are going these days — offering trim levels for various options, but not a lot of picking and choosing beyond that.

Scion officials presented the vehicles during a press unveiling in Philadelphia in September. Let’s see how they did on first glance.

Largish hatchback: When I first saw the iM on the PowerPoint, I immediately noticed how similar it looked to the new France-built Yaris. Up close, the similarities ended pretty quickly.

Advertise with us

Inside: The iM is far roomier than the tiny Toyota. It’s a lot more comfortable; the leather seats on the test vehicles are far more substantial than the short-bottomed Yaris seats.

Upscale touches abound. The shifter is nice with a classy leather boot. The controls seem more upscale than the Yaris. And the heater controls are ebony. While a little hard to intuit at first, they become clear.

On the road: We got a chance to take several examples of the two vehicles through the Drives of Fairmount Park over the course of the afternoon. The 137-horsepower 1.8-liter four-cylinder engine offers enough oomph to power the iM. Handling is a lot more Corolla-like than the Yarisesque.

The CVT logic is OK — a little racy but it shifts fairly well for a CVT. The stick is loose and the clutch is as well. The clutch engages late in the game and the gears so loose they almost don’t follow an H pattern.

Where it’s built: Great Britain and Takaoka, Japan.

Advertise with us

Supertiny sedan: On first glance, the iA looked like a Mazda3. On second glance, too.

Obviously my eyes work, because the iA is in fact a Mazda2 sedan. The Mazda2 hatchback — available here in an early incarnation during the 2012 and 2013 model years — was redesigned to add in Mazda’s KODO design touches, but it was promptly nuked from the Mazda lineup.

Now it’s resurrected without the convenience of a hatchback in such a small vehicle.

Scion says the 13.5 cubic feet of trunk space surpasses a Corolla’s 13.

Inside: The interior is all Mazda, from the instrument pod to the iPad-like infotainment interface with its dial control.

Advertise with us

The Mazda2esque short seat bottoms make getting comfortable a challenge, even for an average-sized male like me. “Brutal” was the adjective I found in my notes.

On the road: The 105-horsepower 1.5-liter engine comes straight from the Yaris, so no socks were knocked off in getting the iA up to speed.

Despite its heritage as a small Mazda, the iA handles like a Toyota — loose steering and lots of body roll.

The six-speed manual’s gears are loose but the iA was not unpleasant to drive. The clutch is forgiving. The automatic shifts like a Mazda as well — the auto pulls backward to upshift, pushes forward to downshift. Automatic logic is depressing, though, and saps the power quickly.

Where it’s built: Salamanca, Mexico.

Advertise with us

In the end: Both are fairly decent products for the money, but I’d lean toward the larger iM. Toyota’s offerings have long been on the high end of the reliability rating, but a tiny Mazda that hails from Mexico doesn’t inspire the same kind of confidence.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.