Like a car limping to the gas station on fumes, depositors of Pittsburgh-area banks know that empty feeling.

Over the last year, the choices for customers looking for free checking accounts have dwindled, while yields on deposits continued to hover at record lows.

Among the region’s top 10 banks, the number offering free, no-minimum-balance checking accounts fell to six, according to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s annual bank fee survey. That was one fewer than a year ago and two fewer than in 2013.

On the upside, among the four banks without free checking — PNC, Citizens, First Niagara and Northwest Savings — customers can get a free account by jumping through a hoop or two.

Advertise with us

Market leader PNC waives the maintenance fee for customers 62 and older, or for anyone who makes at least $500 in direct deposits per month.

At No. 2 Citizens and No. 5 First Niagara, it’s even easier to get a pass. Customers need only to remember to make one deposit per statement period in any amount, even as little as a penny.

And at Northwest, a modest $300 average daily balance will waive the $3-per-month maintenance fee.

PG graphic: Banking account fees

(Click image for larger version)

Advertise with us

Still, free accounts don’t earn interest. Customers at Pittsburgh’s leading banks who want a checking account that pays a return will need to maintain a balance ranging from $1,000 to $5,000. Falling below the minimum triggers a monthly fee ranging from $5 to $15, likely obliterating any interest earned.

Uninspiring interest

Not many tears will be shed over losing today’s nanogram-sized returns.

The average yield on interest-bearing checking accounts among the top 10 banks here is 0.046 percent, up a pinch from 0.036 percent a year earlier. The increase means customers with a $5,000 balance would earn about $2.30 in annual interest, up from about $1.80 last year.

Customers with bigger balances that qualify for higher rates don’t fare much better. The average return on the top-yielding deposit accounts — including checking, savings or money market accounts — is 0.41 percent, up a smidgen from 0.36 percent a year ago.

Advertise with us

That works out to about $82 a year in interest on a $20,000 deposit, compared with about $72 last year.

The higher rates available locally are found at Dollar Bank — where customers with an “Everything Savings” account earn 1.6 percent on balances up to $20,000 and 0.25 percent thereafter — and at PNC, where customers with at least $50,000 earn 0.8 percent on certain accounts.

Periodically, some banks also offer introductory teaser rates to attract new customers.

For example, Citizens Bank is paying 1.35 percent for depositing at least $10,000 in new money, guaranteed through the end of the year. At First Niagara, $25,000 not currently on deposit yields 1.5 percent for the first 90 days, while First Commonwealth Financial is paying 1.5 percent for a limited time for $10,000 in new money.

Penalties still loom

Advertise with us

Puny returns aside, bank customers who let their accounts go negative can quickly find themselves in a deep hole. Overdraft fees among the area’s leading banks range from $25 to $37.50.

In addition to per-item fees, all of the banks except for S&T and Northwest assess an additional fee when an account remains overdrawn for a certain number of days. For example, PNC charges $7 each day an account is overdrawn for five or more days, up to a maximum fee of $98, while First National Bank of Pennsylvania tacks on $12 every three business days with no cap.

Huntington, the No. 6 bank in the region, is unique here for giving customers a 24-hour grace period to get their accounts into the black before assessing any fees.

Until a few years ago, most big banks reordered debit card transactions and checks to process them from highest amount to lowest instead of allowing them to clear chronologically — a procedure that tended to trigger the most overdraft fees.

The much-maligned practice was curbed (particularly in the case of debit card purchases) after a number of consumer lawsuits were filed against the practice nationwide.

Advertise with us

Locally, FNB stands out as the only bank among the top 10 that continues to re-sequence checks and debit card purchases from highest amount to lowest.

The majority of institutions process checks and debit transactions as they are presented, the method favored by consumer advocates. They include PNC, Huntington, S&T and Northwest. First Commonwealth and Wesbanco even go a step further and reorder debit transactions from low to high.

The rest — Citizens, Dollar and First Niagara — clear debit card transactions in the order they come in but reorder checks from high to low. The banks contend checks are handled that way because the biggest checks tend to be for customers’ most important bills.

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066