2015 Cadillac Escalade 4WD Premium: Impress the neighbors.
Price: $90,355 as tested (starting at a mere $84,070 before the $2,000 brown interior with accents, the $1,695 automatic retractable steps, the $995 paint and the $600 wheels)
Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com liked the “available seating for up to eight passengers; strong V8 power; stout towing capacity; quiet interior” but not the “frustrating to use” infotainment interface; “high cargo floor and load height; cramped kids-only third-row seat; rough and jiggly ride.”
Marketer’s pitch: “Our crown jewel, cut and crafted to form.”
Reality: Big and bulky, but beautiful.
Step inside: I’ve been inside the Escalade before, and I’m always amazed at how something so enormous doesn’t really hold a candle to the Sturgis Family Sienna for haulability.
Even with a new look for 2015, it’s still like that. Big hood that you can’t possibly see over, small cargo behind the third row that can’t hold more than a few bags, third-row seating for short people.
Weather or not: The handling remained fine — or should I say it didn’t get more awkward — in some of 2015’s torrential downpours, but the fancy technology slips up in wet weather.
Front and rear cameras, which are pretty much a necessity to park this beast?
Covered in water, you can’t see a thing, so parking the Escalade while on vacation in an unfamiliar town was a nightmare. I’m sure the New Englanders are still laughing about the idiot in the $90,000 Escalade with the New York plates who couldn’t park worth a damn.
On the road: On first drive, the handling was enormously bulky, cumbersome and Toyota Tundralike, so much so that I thought I was really out of practice. Then I found a way to switch from Touring to Sport mode, and things settled down a bit.
Anyway, it still handled like an Escalade, but at least now I felt in control. I guess GM didn’t want to call them Tank mode and Steamship mode.
Still, we followed the narrow, old Henry Hudson Parkway and Saw Mill Road around some traffic jams in the Big Apple, and the Escalade didn’t feel too fat to fit in the skinny lanes.
Up to speed: The 420 horses from the 6.2-liter V-8 motivate the Escalade with some gusto. GM claims a 0-60 time below 6 seconds, but I never thought it was quite that fast. The Escalade is also hampered by the sheer amount of force required to cause the accelerator and brake pedals to do what you want.
Shifty: The eight-speed shiftable transmission handled its functions without note, as good transmissions should.
Friends and stuff: Mrs. Passenger Seat enjoyed her perch next to me just fine, although we agreed the seats were quite firm. Still, we put close to 1,000 miles on this baby — about 2.5 times a typical test drive — and our spines emerged unscathed.
Riders in the middle row will be pleased. But the rear row has a shorter seat on a higher floor. It accommodates three but really needs to stop at two adults.
A new feature for 2015 is fold-flat seats in both rear rows, definitely a big help in loading the beast down with cargo. Still, the Escalade cargo capacity tops out at a large-sounding 95 cubic feet, but that’s less than two thirds a Sienna’s.
Play some tunes: I’m one of the few automotive journalists who thought the CUE system and the funky touch buttons were a neat idea at the outset, but it’s not aging well. Two screens are standard issue in many luxury models, and now I know why. When we couldn’t solve a heating control issue while traveling New England, I lost the ability to read the map until the problem was worked out.
Private messaging: I still like the vibrating seat alerts over chimes and buzzers any day.
Fuel economy: The active fuel management system performed fairly well, shutting down four cylinders without any complaint. I got 18.9 miles to the gallon on a highway-heavy nine-day trip, and only used the recommended premium fuel for about 40 percent of the trip.
Where it’s built: Arlington, Texas.
How it’s built: Consumer Reports doesn’t rate these babies, but factory mates the Suburban and Tahoe get average and above-average ratings in recent years.
In the end: The Escalade was nice, but it wasn’t niiiice. For 90 big ones, I could get a fully loaded Sienna and a BMW 2 Series, and have more fun while hauling way more people and stuff.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.