For years, taxpayers have questioned whether the estimated $70 billion in subsidies governments shower on the free enterprise system each year are savvy investments or corporate welfare run amok.
Soon, they will have more information to make that call.
This month, the Governmental Accounting Standards Board — the Norwalk, Conn., body that oversees government accounting rules — said it will require governments to disclose how much tax revenue they are foregoing because of incentives provided to businesses.
State and local governments, as well as school districts, also will have to disclose the jobs promises and other commitments businesses made in order to avoid paying taxes.
The disclosure must be made in financial statements for fiscal years beginning after Dec. 15.
Information about lost revenue is of interest to taxpayers who could face higher taxes or reduced government services if the incentives do not grow the tax base; to watchdog groups that question whether the incentives make sense; and to bond analysts trying to assess whether the giveaways jeopardize a government’s fiscal integrity.
Critics say while the standards are a significant step forward, they do not go far enough. They wanted GASB to require governments to disclose the value of tax abatements on a company-by-company basis. Instead, they will only be required to disclose the total value of abatements provided under each of their incentive programs.
“It’s really unfortunate that we don’t have company-specific reporting,” said Kenneth Thomas, a political science professor at the University of Missouri-St. Louis.
Mr. Thomas, who came up with the $70 billion price tag for the subsidies, said disclosing information about specific projects would allow taxpayers and policymakers to evaluate how successful the incentives were in creating jobs and increasing the tax base.
“Those questions are all company specific and very important and we can’t get to that information through this reporting,” he said.
A good source for company-specific information on some subsidies is Good Jobs.
Mr. Thomas also faults GASB for not requiring governments to disclose the strain incentives will put on tax revenue in future years.
Phineas Baxandall, senior analyst with the U.S. Public Interest Research Group, wanted governments to be required to report how well subsidy recipients are complying with promises to create or retain jobs or invest in plants or new equipment.
“The new GASB reporting still isn’t designed for government transparency or ensuring accountability for subsidy dollars,” he said in an e-mail.
“It seems designed more for bond buyers to judge how credit-worthy a government is, based partially on how much future revenue it has already foregone,” wrote Mr. Baxandall, whose watchdog organization rates states on how well they disclose company-specific information about subsidies.
Pennsylvania’s Keystone Opportunity Zone, or KOZ, program, illustrates the standard’s shortcomings. KOZ frees recipients from paying a host of taxes, including state corporate income, and sales and use taxes, as well as local corporate income, gross receipts and property taxes.
Recipients of the subsidy include Allegheny Technologies, which is currently locking out about 2,200 members of the United Steelworkers union after failing to negotiate a labor agreement to replace one that expired June 30.
The state already discloses the overall tax bill for the KOZ program: about $70 million annually.
The state does not provide a breakdown of how much of that is attributed to Allegheny Technologies and that won’t change under the new standard — unless the state voluntarily discloses it. Local governments and school districts will have to disclose the revenue impact of participating in the KOZ program, but won’t have to do so on a company-by-company basis.
Some government officials balked at the disclosures. In a letter to GASB this year, the U.S. Conference of Mayors and similar organizations said it’s misleading to disclose how much revenue they are giving up without providing information about the benefits they expect to realize or are realizing from the incentives.
Which begs the question: if these subsidies are all they are cracked up to be, what’s so dangerous about providing detailed information about how much they cost?
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.