Citizens Bank was last week assaulted by regulators from three federal agencies that encumbered their victim with oppressive regulations before making off with about $35 million from Pittsburgh’s second-largest bank.
Perhaps that’s how those who believe unregulated financial markets are the solution would have written the story. But every so often, a company like Citizens comes along to make evident the need for those pesky government rules many businesses complain about.
It’s because sometimes businesses refuse to do the right thing or have a misguided concept of what the right thing is.
The Rhode Island-based bank, second in the Pittsburgh market only to PNC Bank, last week agreed to refund consumer customers at least $11 million, refund another $3 million to business customers, and pay $20.5 million in penalties for routinely cheating depositors out of money. The price tag is expected to rise after one of the agencies involved, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, completes its accounting of just how much Citizens systematically appropriated from customers.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau led the investigation and was assisted by the OCC and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.
So what was it about Citizens’ behavior that this cabal of bureaucrats hellbent on crippling jobs creators found fault with?
The bank inaccurately credited the deposits of some customers between January 2008 and November 2013. During that six-year period, the bank decided it was OK to incorrectly credit customer accounts when there was a discrepancy between what a deposit slip indicated a customer was depositing and the amount of money that actually was deposited. In some cases, the discrepancies occurred because the electronic scanners Citizens used failed to correctly read either the deposit slip or the checks being deposited.
Regulators said at least 475,000 accounts were involved.
“The bank chose to ignore these discrepancies and harmed many consumers by pocketing the difference,” bureau director Richard Cordray said in a statement.
Like a customer too lazy to reconcile a monthly statement with a check register, Citizens decided that it wasn’t necessary to correct those mistakes if the amount involved was, in its opinion, insignificant. At first, it was $50 or less. Later, insignificant meant $25 or less. But as any banker, even one laboring under onerous government regulations, would know, pennies add up.
Citizens maintains the $14 million in refunds represents only the errors it ignored that went against customers. The bank said errors in favor of customers that it ignored totaled about the same amount.
The over- and under-credits to customers were approximately equal, Citizens said. “Customers who were over-credited will keep the excess funds applied to their accounts and customers who were under-credited will be reimbursed,” the bank said in an email to the Post-Gazette’s Patricia Sabatini.
That statement appears to indicate that Citizens is willing to let over-credited customers keep about $14 million — the amount being refunded to under-credited customers — even though the money doesn’t belong to them. Who are we to question their accounting? Perhaps shareholders of Citizens Financial Group, the bank’s Rhode Island-based parent, will make some inquiries about this transfer of shareholder assets.
Regulators said it was the first time they took action against a bank for illegally processing deposits. But Citizens’ email stated that what it did was no different from what other banks do in their desire to make sure deposits are credited to customer accounts the next day, even if the wrong amount is recorded. Mr. Cordray said his agency will take appropriate action if it uncovers similar practices at other institutions.
In its email, Citizens said it was “pleased to have resolved this matter from an earlier era.”
“We strive to do our best for customers every day and do right by customers when issues like this come to light,” the bank wrote.
There’s no doubt Citizens is sincere about that, just as every other banker caught red-handed is sincere in neither admitting or denying guilt and pledging to cease and desist.
Regulators, like businesses, aren’t perfect. They only have employment for life because even the most well-intentioned businesses, from time to time, find it difficult to keep those kinds of promises.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.