For a Driver’s Seat Very Special Used Car Edition, here are some tips on used-car shopping I’ve gleaned over the years.

What not to do: Sometimes a painful lesson is an unforgettable lesson.

At age 23, I “knew” that Mitsubishi made great cars — because they were Japanese right? — so for a family vehicle I zeroed in on a used-up, rusted-out clunker of a Mitsubishi-made Plymouth Colt Vista. Its low price fit our budget; its seven tiny seats fit our then-tiny family; and it handled well and seemed clean enough.

We got off to a bad start. I fought to have the engine replaced within the 30-day warranty period — it had a two-quart-per-day oil habit — and, luckily, won. I paid an ungodly amount and waited two weeks for run-of-the-mill parts like a brake caliper and a CV joint.

Advertise with us

So I started preparing for my next used car purchase years in advance as if I were a med student studying for the MCAT. It paid off, as my used car purchases since then have turned out fairly well — knock wood — and I found great sources of information that I rely on to this day.

Find reliable sources: For me, that’s been Edmunds.com for reviews, ease of comparison and pricing; and the annual publication The Car Book by Jack Gillis and Clarence Ditlow, and Consumer Reports, for reliability data.

When I contacted Mr. Gillis, who is public affairs director for the Consumer Federation of America in Washington, D.C., his first words to me offered buyers a glimmer of hope: Buying a used car today is no longer an exercise in buying somebody else’s troubles.

“Because of leasing and the general turnover in vehicles, there are a tremendous number of good used cars in the marketplace,” Mr. Gillis said.

And cars coming off lease are on the rise, according to Carroll Lachnit, features editor for Edmunds.com.

Advertise with us

“For the first time in the past three or four years, newer used cars are dominating the used car market — 66 percent now,” Mr. Lachnit said.

A good used car should make it to 150,000 miles with minimum maintenance, Mr. Gillis said.

That’s the good news. But how does one find the elusive good used car for the right price?

Pick out what you want in a price range that works: I’ve used Edmunds’ True Market Value estimator since 2000 as a starting point for every used car purchase. The tool gives buyers a look at the trade-in value, plus prices for a private-party sale, dealer price and certified used price.

At a dealer, I’m satisfied with landing somewhere between private-party and dealer prices.

Advertise with us

“I think it’s giving people more information, and information is power in negotiation,” Mr. Lachnit said.

Show us the Carfax: This has become the industry standard for gathering data on used cars that have been through a crash, a flood or some other untoward event.

But it’s only one tool, with limited applications.

“A perfectly clean CarFax report doesn’t necessarily mean a perfectly clean car,” Mr. Gillis said, “but it should be something on your checklist of things to check when buying a used car.”

CarFax once steered me clear of a car that had an R-title, which means it was declared a total loss by an insurance company after a crash, flood or some other mishap, and then rebuilt.

Advertise with us

Spend some time on a test drive: When you decide a car is not for you, leave the dealer fast. Don’t be polite and get talked into something you’re not sure of.

But when you decide on something, spend some time with it.

“Take it out for a good long test drive,” Mr. Gillis said. “That’s something that consumers don’t do.”

People want to get a sense of anything that might annoy them over the long haul — the things I whine about week in and week out.

My advice? Ask to keep the car overnight. Take it home. Drive it around the places you live, work, and shop. Fill it with groceries. Whatever it is you normally do in your car.

Advertise with us

Have it inspected: A trusted mechanic is a used-car buyer’s best friend.

“A trained professional can pick up things that may not cause you not to buy the vehicle but at least you’re informed about certain issues,” Mr. Gillis said. Problems that are not deal breakers can be used to negotiate a better price.

The overnight visit and the mechanic’s inspection are absolute requirements for my money. I passed on a superbly priced Toyota Sienna from a used-car dealer because the sales staff was hesitant about this.

I’ve even done this with private sellers; we swap cars, so there’s a mutually assured destruction element involved. Of course, one of my life’s most awkward conversations came when I had to refuse a car after the mechanic gave it the thumbs-down.

Your mileage may vary.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.