Let’s get a few things straight from the start: CEO pay has been excessive for some time, and all the vituperating by well-meaning reformers intent on shaming chief executives into accepting more reasonable paychecks has been — and most likely will continue to be — in vain.
Last week’s decision by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission to approve rules for disclosing the ratio between what a company pays its CEO and the median pay of its workforce isn’t going to change those facts of life. At least not any time soon.
The SEC’s action implements a measure Congress authorized five years ago when it enacted sweeping financial legislation known as Dodd-Frank. The law mandated that public companies disclose the ratio of the pay of their CEO and the median pay of its workforce.
This seemingly straightforward mandate allowed Congress to look as if it were responding to populist concerns in the wake of the financial crisis by forcing companies to make a disclosure comparable to a “perp walk,” parading high-profile criminals before the media. In its infinite wisdom, Congress left the excruciatingly difficult work of writing formal rules to the SEC, the fall guy for another episode of legislative folly.
After nearly two years of intense lobbying, the SEC’s five commissioners last week came up with rules for calculating the ratio. Their 3-2 vote along party lines reflects the ongoing debate over how much is too much — or whether too much is not enough — when it comes to CEO pay.
The new rules provide more fuel for that fire. As if the 1,500 individual letters and more than 285,000 form letters the SEC received from parties commenting on the proposal weren’t fuel enough.
Critics of the proposal contend it will be too difficult and too costly for companies to calculate median worker pay. Computing the ratio, in the words of the Business Roundtable, “would be unduly costly and burdensome” and “would generate immaterial, if not misleading, information to investors.”
Granted, it may take some time and talent to round up payroll figures from dozens of countries and to tally it for full- and part-time workers as well as seasonal and temporary employees. But does it strike anyone as disingenuous that companies can calculate the savings from moving operations overseas but can’t determine the size of their payroll, a number they frequently employ when making their relentless pleas for government subsidies?
In an attempt to mollify those concerns, the SEC’s rules contain provisions designed to make the math easier. Small companies are exempt. So are emerging growth companies. Those that have to make the calculation can rely on statistical sampling, exclude some foreign workers, and, under certain conditions, will only have to make the calculation every three years instead of annually.
But the agency’s well-intentioned attempt to abide by the spirit of the mandate Congress gave it while being reasonable about implementing it wasn’t enough to keep some opponents happy.
Rep. Jeb Hensarling, R-Texas, chairman of the House Financial Services Committee and no friend of the SEC, said the partisan vote by the commissioners “is the latest example of the SEC squandering its resources on rulemakings that ... harm U.S. companies and investors.” Seldom one to understate his argument, Mr. Hensarling raised the specter of the regulation costing companies so much that they will have to lay off workers in order to comply.
Proponents of the measure said disclosing the ratio will put a CEO’s compensation in a better context and provide information that is useful to investors. One of those supporters, the AFL-CIO, annually compiles its own ratio by comparing what the CEOs of major U.S. companies make with the annual pay of the average production and nonsupervisory worker. This year, the ratio stands at 373-to-1: $13.5 million for the CEOs and $36,000 for the salt of the earth.
Don’t be surprised if two years from now, when the regulations take effect, that ratio is wider. While former U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis is often quoted as saying “sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants,” CEO pay has thus far proven largely immune to a cleansing.
Eventually, there will be a price paid for not addressing this issue. But for the time being, Congress’ posturing and the SEC’s rulemaking won’t be the demise of CEOs having it made in the shade.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.