Cargo competition: 2015 Volkswagen Golf SportWagen TDI vs. 2015 Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium vs. 2016 Mazda CX-5 Grand Touring.
This week: On the road.
Power: The SportWagen comes with choice of 1.8-liter turbocharged gasoline engine making 170 horsepower or a 150-horsepower TDI engine in the vehicle I tested.
The Subaru’s 2.5-liter horizontally opposed four-cylinder produces 175 horsepower. The engine was a peppy unit but not all that smooth.
The CX-5 came with the larger 2.5-liter SkyActiv four (a 2.0-liter is also available). The 2.5 is fairly underpowered and not up to high speeds on hills, although straightforward pullouts are fine.
Shifty: Oh, how I longed for a stick in the SportWagen. Volkswagen clutches tend to be easy to use and forgiving, but, alas, it was not to be.
The shiftable six-speed automatic worked well. Automatic mode could be less than smooth, especially when the car was warming up. Shifting the levers myself was pleasant, with good feedback and response.
Either way, people who enjoy shifting with or without clutch will get a more spirited ride in the SportWagen. The power is good, but it needs to be mated to just the right gear.
The Subaru is designed for people who aren’t concerned about driving fun. The CVT is not badly done, but it still gives a golf-cart feeling to the acceleration, especially on hills. Drivers can “shift” but this is not directly tied to the transmission and doesn’t allow for much control.
The CX-5 features a shiftable automatic, and drivers will experience a lot of shifts whether they move the stick themselves or not. The overdrive 5th and 6th gears mean any passing — and even light hill climbing — has to be done in 4th. And the power curve seems to drop off dramatically after 40 mph or so.
On the road: The Golf SportWagen handled even better than the nimble Golf hatchback I tested recently. One would think that tacking a bigger butt onto the original vehicle would make it feel like a whale in the water, but nothing is sacrificed in handling and maneuverability.
The Outback handled very Subaru-like. The Foresters and Imprezas I’ve driven thus far have had a very direct feel. It’s not a lot of fun, but it offers a feeling of security.
One disappointment about the Outback was a great abundance of wind noise. I kept checking to see that I didn’t leave a window open. And on a night of heavy rains, either wind noise or wiper noise — or some combination of the two — made it sound like a ghost was accompanying me home.
The Outback also comes with a great deal of lean in the hard turns, even more than most crossovers.
The CX-5 did not live up to Mazda’s usual standard for sporty performance. Sport mode was a little rough, and cornering seemed sloppy and not that fun.
Night shift: SportWagen occupants will find the cabin lighting clear. Controls from the front operate the rear lights separately as well, a nice touch. But seeing the road with the interior light on can be a challenge.
Good lighting, like good design, should not draw attention to itself, and the Subaru had that handled. But rear occupants only got a center light in my test vehicle.
The CX-5 features two lights in the rear, but they’re paired in the center rather than tucked in each corner.
Fuel economy: The SportWagen was hands-down the winner in this category, with its turbo diesel powerplant. I averaged 39 mpg, and the price of diesel is at a premium.
The Outback averaged about 26.5 mpg in the usual round of Mr. Driver’s Seat testing.
Surprisingly, the CX-5 was the piggy of the group, averaging just under 25 mpg.
Where they’re built: The Volkswagen comes to us from Puebla, Mexico; the Subaru from Lafayette, Ind.; and the Mazda from Hiroshima, Japan.
How they’re built: The Mazda rocks a top reliability rating from Consumer Reports, and the Outback just a notch below it. The SportWagen doesn’t get a rating as a new model, but Volkswagens not built in Chattanooga, Tenn., have generally landed about average.
In the end: I’m surprised by my results. I expected the CX-5 — which handled nicely and got much better mileage in tests around its introduction three years ago — to top the group, but I’d have to put it on the bottom rung, although I’d miss the sound system immensely. And that reliability is a good selling point.
Though the Outback has much to recommend it, I’d lean toward the SportWagen just for the total package.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.