Usually, investors shrug their shoulders when a company posts quarterly results in line with estimates. Unless the quarterly report includes an unexpectedly upbeat or downbeat forecast for the months ahead, the stock doesn’t move much because the company delivered what it was expected to deliver.
Allegheny Technologies is the exception to the rule.
On Tuesday, the Pittsburgh specialty metals reported a second quarter loss of $16.4 million, results that were at the rosier end of the $16 million to $18 million loss the company forecast a week earlier. But the company’s shares tumbled nearly 14 percent Tuesday and shed another 5 percent Wednesday. A rebound Thursday left them down about 37 percent for the year.
The woes besetting Allegheny Technologies — a crush of price-depressing imports, massive global overcapacity, a stronger U.S. dollar, weak demand from the oil industry, an anemic U.S. economic recovery — plague other steel producers as well.
Despite $340 million in benefits so far this year from CEO Mario Longhi’s vaunted Carnegie Way cost-cutting and efficiency initiative, U.S. Steel shares are down about 36 percent this year through Thursday. After losing $75 million, or 52 cents per share, in the first quarter, Mr. Longhi warned of tough times ahead given import levels and the slowdown in the oil patch.
Analysts expect the Pittsburgh steelmaker to report a loss of 68 cents per share when it posts second quarter results this week.
Dreary industry statistics explain why steel stocks aren’t getting any love. According to the American Iron and Steel Institute, shipments from U.S. mills are down nearly 11 percent through May; imports are up 3 percent from elevated levels a year ago and have captured about a third of the market; steel production is down 8 percent; and U.S. mills are operating at only about 73 percent of capacity.
There’s an overwhelming déjà vu quality to the bleak steel landscape. Steel executives are once again griping about cheap, unfairly traded imports, many of them produced by government-subsidized competitors. Many steel industry officials compare the current climate to 1998, when a surge in imports eventually led to bankruptcy for more than 40 steel producers, according to the United Steelworkers union.
On a conference call with analysts Tuesday discussing the company’s second quarter results, Rich Harshman, Allegheny Technologies chairman, president and CEO, cited a nearly 150 percent increase in imports from China in the first five months of this year. Some of the deluge can be traced to the European Union filing trade complaints against Chinese producers, which are now diverting their steel to the U.S. market, he said.
USW president Leo Gerard believes part of the problem is that the U.S. lacks a comprehensive industrial policy that acknowledges the importance of manufacturing. All we have to fall back on, Mr. Gerard told members of the House Steel Caucus in March, are “trade laws built on an injury test that requires massive bloodletting before any relief is available.”
Those laws allow steel companies to file trade cases seeking tariffs on unfairly traded imports. It is a costly, time-consuming process that can take months to provide relief. Mr. Harshman told analysts trade cases will likely be filed against China and perhaps other countries.
Thomas Gibson, president of the American Iron and Steel Institute, said there are several significant differences between current import crisis and the one in 1998.
Foremost, compared to the third of the U.S. market imports currently own, foreign producers only had a 26 percent share of the U.S. market in 1998, according to AISI statistics. Moreover, at 1.3 billion tons of capacity — far beyond its domestic needs — China’s steel industry is significantly larger than it was then, Mr. Gibson said. He added that U.S. economic growth following that crisis was stronger than the lackluster growth following the 2008 recession. Finally, China’s slowing growth means there are fewer domestic customers to sop up that country’s excess steel capacity.
In 1998, the steel industry’s habitual complaints about imports did not inspire U.S. policymakers to engineer the elusive level playing field domestic producers eternally seek. Unless they are is backed by political will, the industry’s latest lamentations will prove no match for China’s mercantilist policies.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.