Cargo competition: 2015 Volkswagen Golf SportWagen TDI vs. 2015 Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium vs. 2016 Mazda CX-5 Grand Touring.

Prices: The SportWagen was $31,605; the Outback was $31,535; and the CX-5 was $33,840, all equipped as tested. The Subaru started out cheapest before options at $26,995; the SportWagen next at $28,525; and the Mazda $29,470.

Conventional wisdom: Edmunds says the Golf SportWagen sports “premium cabin materials and construction; more interior room; refined driving dynamics” but suffers from “sluggish automatic transmission response could carry over; TDI carries a premium price.”

For the Outback, we learn of the “spacious and comfortable interior; efficient engines; excellent visibility; above-average off-road ability; top safety scores,” while bemoaning the “base engine’s lackluster acceleration.”

Advertise with us

For the CX-5, Edmunds notes “engaging driving experience; fuel-efficient engines; roomy, comfortable seating; excellent crash test scores; sharp styling,” while panning the “mediocre electronics interface; subpar stereo sound quality; weak acceleration with base engine.”

Marketer’s pitches: The Sportwagen is dubbed “More room, more power, more Golf.” Subaru calls itself “Confidence in motion” but is more straightforward on selling its Outback, without any cute phrases. The CX-5 is called “The overachiever of its class.”

Serious competition: After a Golf SportWagen landed in my driveway, I thought “Ruh-roh. This wasn’t smart, Sturgis.” Being an auto columnist of very little brain, I realized I’d just written about the Golf and Jetta, and this really wasn’t all that different upon first glance.

So I decided to look backward – not in what I’d written before, but in what lay physically behind me as I sat in the Driver’s Seat. Which competitors offer roughly the same amount of cargo space (66.5 cubic feet for the VW) as the new-for-2015 German unit? Lo, the Outback and the CX-5, and a test was born.

This week, we’ll introduce them. Next week, we’ll sit inside. But no one gets to go for a ride until the final week. And you readers behave, or I’ll turn this test right around.

Advertise with us

Something new: The Golf SportWagen is the only newbie for 2015. It replaces the Jetta SportWagen, which was most memorable for … well, no one really remembers it, because no one bought it. Only 8,571 were sold through May of 2014. The Golf is not on its way to better results … 3,120 sold in the same period in 2015.

The Mazda CX-5 may seem like odd competition for the SportWagen, but at about 65 cubic feet with the rear seat folded, it’s right in the neighborhood of SportWagen storage. The Outback is the big, old Papa Bear of the group with 73 cubic feet, and really the big, old Great Great Granddaddy bear of the group, in existence since the mid-1990s.

But while the Outback has been around for a long while, it did get a new look for 2015, with more space and efficiency added to the mix, and a standard CVT.

The CX-5 debuted in the 2013 model year.

How they compare: The CX-5 and Outback obviously stand a lot taller than the SportWagen. The Mazda is about Mrs. Passenger Seat height, just shy of 5½ feet tall, while the Outback clears the 66-inch mark by a few ticks. At 58.3 inches, the SportWagen is the sports car of the crew.

Advertise with us

The CX-5 and Outback give buyers 8.5 and 8.7 inches of ground clearance respectively, while the SportWagen gives a measly 5.5.

And of course, the two crossovers offer all-wheel drive, while the Volkswagen does not. Something called the Golf SportWagen Alltrack looms on the horizon, though, for the 2017 model year.

Outside: The SportWagen cuts a handsome profile. Fourteen-year-old Sturgis Kid 4.0 mentioned how nice he thought it looked, and I have to agree.

The new Outback keeps getting swoopier and swoopier. Good for the fuel economy, but not so much to attract my eye.

The CX-5 offers a classic look I liked from its 2013 debut.

Advertise with us

Next week: A closer look inside the vehicles.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.