When the Supreme Court ruled in favor of the right to same-sex marriage, James Lange of Squirrel Hill breathed a sigh of relief — but not for the obvious reasons.
“I realized there was a tremendous opportunity that nobody was talking about. [Everybody was] talking about love and affection and the Constitution and legal rights. Nobody was talking how [this decision] could make the difference between being broke and comfortable and, if you’re already doing well, between doing very well and just OK if you decided to get married,” Mr. Lange, a CPA and an attorney, said.
Months before the ruling, Mr. Lange wrote a book advising gay couples to get married titled “Live Gay, Retire Rich” ($17.99, Retire Secure Press). He admits that making such a decision before gay marriage was legalized nationwide was a “gamble” but he spent time researching the Supreme Court justices and took a chance that Justice Anthony Kennedy, the swing vote, would vote in favor.
“I kind of appointed myself as the person to write the book and then wrote it. I got testimonials from … IRA and Social Security experts and even a few celebrities,” he said.
Mr. Lange said gay couples who don’t have children tend to leave money to their partners first and then to their siblings, nieces and nephews. That often means that the family of the person who dies first could inherit nothing. In such a scenario, Mr. Lange sometimes advises couples to write a will that leaves money to each other first and then some specifically to family members.
Nine years ago Jack Hilliard, 68, and partner Gary Smith, 74, of Whitehall entered a civil union in Burlington, Vt. When gay marriage became legal in Vermont three years ago, they married, but that union wasn’t recognized in Pennsylvania until last year. The couple, clients of Mr. Lange, acknowledge they married in part to preserve their wealth.
“In Pennsylvania, there is a 15 percent inheritance tax, but if you have a spouse, there is no inheritance at all,” Mr. Hilliard said. “If we didn’t marry, Gary would have to pay a lot of taxes [assuming I died first]. He could have afforded it, but it would have been unpleasant.”
As to the advice on income tax filing status, the answer is less clear.
Mr. Lange recommends that couples “run the numbers” for married filing jointly and compare that with what was paid in taxes as two single taxpayers.
Another dimension in the discussion is how companies are handling tax benefits and partner benefits such as health insurance, dependent life insurance and bereavement leave in light of the recent Supreme Court decision. Some employers already provided same-sex couples with “partner benefits” even though they weren’t married.
“Now that same-sex marriage was legalized, a lot of organizations are rethinking if they need [to provide partner benefits to unmarried same-sex couples]. If they’re really a couple, they should get married. That might force people to get married because costs like health care can be very significant, particularly if somebody has a pre-existing condition,” Mr. Lange said.
One of the city’s large employers, the University of Pittsburgh, does not have any plans to discontinue domestic partnership benefits for same-sex or opposite-sex couples.
In terms of tax benefits, Joe Miksch, interim director of university news, said that “benefits for the partner of the Pitt employee in both same-sex and opposite-sex domestic partnerships are considered taxable income by the federal and state governments.”
“Now that the [Supreme Court] ruling has come through, if same-sex domestic partners marry, benefits will be considered a pretax benefit, just as is the case for any other marriage.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.