Some lager lovers and ale addicts don’t have a clue about who makes the “craft” beer they think they’re drinking.

And they can get pretty upset when they find out.

Take self-described beer aficionado Evan Parent. The San Diego resident said he willingly paid a premium price for Blue Moon beer when he thought he was purchasing a craft beer. In 2012, Mr. Parent discovered the brew is owned and made by megabrewer MillerCoors. The shocking news prompted him to boycott Blue Moon.

Three years later, Mr. Parent is taking it up a notch.

Advertise with us

In April, he filed a class action lawsuit accusing MillerCoors of disseminating “untrue, misleading, and deceptive advertising” to make beer lovers think Blue Moon is a craft beer. Drinkers pay a premium of $2 to $3 per six-pack to buy craft beers, Mr. Parent noted in his lawsuit.

Who is brewing what has become more of an issue in recent years as MillerCoors and Anheuser-Busch InBev struggle with declining sales or sluggish growth in most of their megabrands. Sales of craft beer went up nearly 18 percent last year, according to the Brewers Association. The group, whose members include brewers, home brewers and distributors, said overall beer sales rose less than 1 percent in 2014.

Megabrewers have responded to the languid market by acquiring full or partial stakes in craft beers.

MillerCoors also owns Leinenkugel’s. Anheuser-Busch InBev’s growing stable of craft brews includes Goose Island, Elysian, Blue Point and 10 Barrel. The Belgium-based brewer also owns a 32 percent stake in the Craft Brew Alliance, a publicly traded company whose brands include Redhook, Kona and Widmer Brothers.

Mr. Parent claims that people like him who didn’t know any better and bought Blue Moon were willing to pay more for it because the advertising led them to believe it was a craft beer. Moreover, had they known the truth, they may have bought another beer, his lawsuit states.

Advertise with us

A major basis for Mr. Parent’s claim is that Blue Moon does not meet the Brewers Association’s definition of a craft beer. The industry group defines a craft brewer as someone who brews 6 million gallons annually or less; is less than 25 percent owned by an alcoholic beverage company that is not a craft brewer; and makes the majority of its beer from traditional ingredients and fermentation.

Andrew Price, an attorney with the Milwaukee firm of Reinhart Boerner Van Deuren, said it remains to be seen whether courts will uphold that definition.

Beer snobs can be just as persnickety as wine snobs. Revelations that a megabrewer had something to do with the beer they’re drinking make them apoplectic. Once they calm down, some of them call an attorney.

“There have been problems in labeling and marketing, but the Blue Moon complaint is a poor example,” said Pittsburgh attorney Cris Hoel, whose clients include members of the beer industry.

He described Mr. Parent’s lawsuit as “lawyers thirsting for a claim on behalf of clients thirsting for a settlement.”

Advertise with us

There is precedent for such parched behavior.

Anheuser-Busch is offering to settle two class action lawsuits brought on behalf of Kirin and Beck’s drinkers who thought they were buying imported beers, not something made in the U.S.

Under the terms of the Kirin settlement, drinkers who saved their receipts would be entitled to refunds of up to $50. Those who lack proof of purchase can collect up to $12. The basis of the Beck’s lawsuit is that Anheuser-Busch continues marketing the beer in the U.S., including selling it for a premium price as if it’s made in Germany, when in fact it’s made in St. Louis.

Mr. Hoel said U.S. drinkers probably wouldn’t want to sip a beer made in Japan or Germany. Not only would shipping the beer add to its cost, the voyage could compromise its quality, he said.

“There are many good reasons not to ship beers thousands and thousands of miles,” Mr. Hoel said.

Advertise with us

His sober judgment notwithstanding, brewers would do well to review their labeling and marketing to determine whether any of the content could provoke a lawsuit. Mr. Price advised.

“What I’m curious to see is if plaintiffs’ attorneys in these kinds of claims are going to get even more creative,” Mr. Price said.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.