2015 Ford Mustang I4 Coupe Premium: Four-banger ’Stang for the slow lane?
Price: $35,665 as tested. ($29,170 base price for the cylinder; options not noted below include adaptive cruise control for $1,195; and voice-activated navigation for $795.)
Marketer’s pitch: “Awesome performance and eye-catching style.”
Conventional wisdom: A four-cylinder Mustang? Is this the Mustang II all over again?
Reality: Pony express.
A horse of a different color: A Ford rep contacted me out of the blue and wondered if I’d like to try the 2.3-liter Mustang. Eager to check out the 2015 redesign, I agreed. I knew it wouldn’t compare to the Boss 302 version I’d driven in 2012. Right?
And yet … : Set the drive mode to “track” — chuckle over the picture of the racing helmet — and you’ll quickly see this is no 1974 Mustang II with an 88-horsepower 2.3-liter engine. Get ready to smell some rubber and listen to some growling; there’s 310 horses in this power plant.
Driver’s Seat: But first, let’s idle a moment and admire the view. Let’s offer a prayer to Lido A. Iacocca, who created the Pony Car more than 50 years ago. He and his colleagues crafted one of the most striking interiors for the 1960s Mustangs (and the slightly larger cousin, the Mercury Cougar).
I spent a lot of time inside versions of both cars as a lad and find this newest Mustang incarnation meets all the classic styling standards. The round, telescoping gauges; the slick rolling heater controls; the circular vents — this may be one of the prettiest interiors out there.
Let’s go: Enough chitchat. Press the accelerator down in track mode and you’ll be gone in a hurry. Sixty mph comes in just 5.6 seconds, according to Motor Trend testing. A quarter-mile passes by in 14.1.
Sure, it’s not the 302 GT, but what’s 1.1 seconds (as Car and Driver recorded a 4.5-second 0-60 in a GT)?
Shifty: No clutch pedal in the tester, but the six-speed shiftable automatic worked well in either mode. A six-speed stick is also available, and knocks $1,195 off the price.
Fuel economy: Neither the GT nor the Boss Mustang is going to produce 26 mpg like this baby did, even while driving an all-out assault of impressive starts and pressed-to-the-limits cornering designed to impress Mrs. Passenger Seat.
On the road: When I put the Mustang up against the Camaro and Challenger a few years back, I found the Ford to be by far the most mannerly of the three. I haven’t gone head to head this time, but since then I’ve had the pleasure of driving sport sedans from Lexus, Acura and BMW, and the Mustang holds its own for being direct and in control.
Friends and stuff: Or, perhaps, former friends. The friends who don’t ride shotgun will be very disappointed, indeed. In the back seat, foot room and legroom are nonexistent until the driver shrinks back down to about 5 feet even.
The real catch — literally — comes when the car is shut off, and the power-operated driver’s seat begins its automatic journey rearward to allow the driver to escape. We performed this particular feat of derring-do accidentally while I was mid-dismount from the rear seat, and Sturgis Kid 4.0 had a long bout of voluminous, doubled-over laughter.
When that stops entertaining, Mustang occupants will find the console holds about four CDs, and has a small slot for cell phones as well.
Play some tunes: Speaking of CDs, the sound from the stereo system is not bad.
The Mustang uses Ford’s touch-screen system, now infamous, but Ford has made the improvements promised and it’s smooth to operate. The sound tab is in one corner, the navigation tab in another, and HVAC in the other. Click on the tab to maximize that function. The special sound system was part of a $1,795 package. Touch-screen buttons, though, still are more difficult to operate than actual buttons.
Also, temperature is an issue: The cabin heated up enough on a 65-degree sunny day that my hands were about the temperature around the touch screen, so its operation became limited. Joysticks work better.
Where it’s built: Flat Rock, Mich.
How it’s built: The 2015 model is all new, so it doesn’t get a reliability rating from Consumer Reports. But the Mustang overall has trending downward over the last five years — yet much of this is due to multimedia interface glitches.
Final lap: The Boss may very well be The Boss, but if you’re not taking the car to the track every weekend, even the GT’s 435 horsepower will be a bit much. And out on the highway, the 302 in the 2012 model felt bored and looking for trouble.
I’d gallop for the Mustang — even the four-cylinder — without looking back.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.