Shareholders of Allegheny Technologies [ticker: ATI] have put the Pittsburgh specialty metals producer in rare company.
At its annual meeting in Boston last month, only 49 percent of shareholders supported the company’s executive compensation plan, according to Semler Brossy, a Los Angeles consulting firm that keeps tabs on say-on-pay shareholder votes.
Shareholders at only 20 other companies in the Russell 3000 have rejected pay plans, according Semler Brossy’s May 27 report. On average, 92 percent of shareholders have backed company pay plans in votes this year, the consulting firm reported.
The votes were mandated by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission in 2010. They are only advisory, and companies that get failing votes are not required to do anything.
Last year, 97 percent of Allegheny Technologies shareholders approved the company’s compensation plan. This year, two firms that advise institutional shareholders on proxy voting recommended rejecting the specialty metals producer’s compensation plan.
Glass Lewis said that although the company has made some improvements, “We remain concerned by the company’s continued failure to appropriately align executive compensation with corporate performance.” The firm has given the pay plan an F in every year but one since 2009. Glass Lewis gave it a D last year.
ISS Proxy Advisory Services also credited Allegheny Technologies with improving pay practices, but added that the “changes do not appear to have fully addressed underlying pay for performance concerns” for 2014. ISS said the company paid executives generous cash incentives last year even though it generated negative one-, three- and five-year returns.
“The above-target cash payouts raise particular concern given that a majority of the financial goals were achieved below threshold levels necessary to trigger a payout,” ISS wrote in its analysis.
Allegheny Technologies chairman, president and CEO Richard Harshman received compensation valued at $8 million last year.
♦ ♦ ♦ ♦
Given the habitual failure of the White House and Congress to address the nation’s crumbling infrastructure, what’s happening at the Montgomery and New Cumberland locks on the Ohio River is no surprise.
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers announced May 21 that deteriorating conditions are forcing the agency to close the auxiliary lock chambers at Montgomery, located in Monaca, and New Cumberland, farther down the river in Stratton, Ohio. The Corps cited “severe structural deterioration and widespread fatigue cracking” of the lock gates at New Cumberland and said it cannot complete a structural analysis at Montgomery until debris is dredged from the lock chamber.
Repairs are not expected to be completed until next spring.
Fortunately, both facilities have main locks that will remain open. About 300 tows of barges pass through Montgomery and New Cumberland each month, as well as 125 or more pleasure vehicles during the summer months. So far, closing the auxiliary locks has not resulted in significant traffic delays, a Corps spokesman said last week.
However, the Corps warns that should either of the main locks fail, the Ohio River could close to traffic.
The fact that the Corps’ Pittsburgh office oversees what it describes as “the largest, oldest, and most fatigued navigation system in the nation” makes failure at either lock more of a possibility than some may believe. Failure is even more likely on the Monongahela River, where the movement of coal and other commodities hinges on a 108-year-old dam at Elizabeth.
The dam was supposed to be long gone under a $750 million project approved by Congress in 1992. But Congress’ failure to fund the work resulted in cost overruns and construction delays. Supposed to have been completed in 2004 at a cost of $750 million, the project is now expected to cost $2.7 billion and may not be completed for a decade or more.
That’s consistent with Congress’ approach to highway funding. Last month, Congress replaced an eight-month patch for the debilitated Highway Trust Fund, enacted last summer, with a two-month extension. As if another 60 days will be enough time for members of Congress to summon the courage to craft a long-term solution.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.