The drugstore chain Rite Aid Corp. was a little late to the loyalty game, launching its Wellness+ program about five years ago. But now, 80 percent of sales are made to the program’s members — it has about 25 million — and the card has helped retain the chain’s best customers.

“Why change it?” asked John Learish, the Camp Hill-based drugstore retailer’s senior vice president of marketing. “Why would we risk giving up some of that equity to join a coalition program?”

But Rite Aid has done just that by signing on as one of the founding partners in a new coalition loyalty program that will link other major brands including Macy’s, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Exxon, Mobil, AT&T and Nationwide.

Plenti, as the loyalty program is named, is being organized and run by an American Express operation that has experience with similar programs in Europe, where coalition efforts have been more successful than in the U.S.

Advertise with us

The goal is to bring even more partners into the project — allowing members to earn points on purchases at the various businesses that can be used at other partner businesses.

Loyalty programs abound in U.S. retail, even if the debate over their effectiveness continues. American consumers hold 3.3 billion memberships in loyalty programs, a 26 percent increase in the past two years, according to a report released in February by Cincinnati marketing research firm Colloquy.

The research firm found American households have signed up for memberships in an average of 29 loyalty programs, but actually use 12. Active membership — defined as earning or redeeming at least once a year — dropped over the two-year period.

“That marks the beginning of a trend, as the active rate declined for the first time in the 2013 report,” Colloquy’s announcement said.

When the Plenti program was announced in March, the organizers cited research that said 72 percent of Americans want a single rewards program that could be used at a lot of different places.

Advertise with us

Most of the founding partners, such as Rite Aid, already have their own versions of rewards programs, so the new project will involve some tinkering and some educating of customers.

Houston, Texas-based Direct Energy, which has customers across Pennsylvania, will be phasing out its DE Rewards program to shift to the Plenti program over the next few months, a company spokeswoman said. Macy’s, which links its Star rewards program to its store credit card, noted on its website that some changes will be coming to that program.

Mr. Learish, at Rite Aid, said the Wellness+ program had reached a saturation point in the company’s customer base. “We needed a way to try to reinvigorate the program,” he said.

Now members will be able to earn both Wellness+ rewards and Plenti points at the same time, depending on that week’s offers and their purchases, And that may drive new sales as Rite Aid gets in front of Macy’s or Hulu customers who don’t usually patronize the drugstore chain.

That’s true for all of the brand partners. Customers who usually stop at a Sunoco station might be convinced to get gas from Exxon in order to order earn Plenti points.

Advertise with us

Mr. Learish estimated the brands involved spend a total of about $3 billion on marketing each year, so he expects consumers will see a lot of marketing around the card that should help raise awareness.

Teresa F. Lindeman: tlindeman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2018