Carmakers have gotten more adept at bringing better driving experiences to the masses, but one particular development may not be best where the rubber meets the road.
Over the past several years, low-profile tires designed to provide excellent handling and steering feedback — and in part to accommodate larger brake systems — have moved out of the realm of sports and performance cars into a broader variety of luxury cars, SUVs and even regular sedans.
But they may have met their match in today’s harsher winters and tighter highway and streets department budgets.
A tired Mercedes owner: Philadelphia-area attorney David Schiller knows this all too well.
Mr. Schiller was so happy with his 2006 Mercedes E320 diesel and two previous Mercedes models that, when he went shopping for a new car in May, he picked up a used 2013 Mercedes S550.
Unfortunately, after less than a year and six replaced tires, the S550 is put away until pothole season has passed. “Meanwhile, I’m driving a car with 130,000 miles,” Mr. Schiller said.
On top of that, service records from the previous owner show that three tires were replaced before he even bought the car.
That’s nine tires in two years!
How did we arrive here? Once upon a time, tires were all pretty standard sizes.
Think of it in terms of a pizza: The wheel is the cheese and sauce part — and toppings, if you’re so inclined — and the tire is the crust. If you decide to slide the entire pizza down the kitchen counter — showing off for the kids — a thick-crust pizza that accidentally smashes into the coffeemaker will protect the toppings and sauce much better than thin crust. (Kids, don’t try this at home.)
Before about the turn of the millennium, most passenger cars came with a wheel that had a 13- to 15-inch diameter (sauce), and the tire itself added a good six or seven inches of rubber insulation (crust) around the wheel. That’s a good bit of steel-belted rubber compounds to blunt the force of potholes and other road imperfections (coffeemaker).
Mr. Schiller’s S550 has 255/35ZR20 tires, which means a tire is 255 millimeters wide, about 90 millimeters tall, and sits on a 20-inch diameter wheel (18- and 19-inch wheels are also available on other versions of the S550). But that 35 series tire only adds about 3.5 inches of rubber around the wheel, said John Rastetter, director of tire information services at Tirerack.com.
What can you do about it? The experts say people shopping for a car need to know what kind of tires are going to be on the vehicle they’re considering.
Mr. Rastetter says this: “Unless it’s incredibly important to you, don’t be tempted by the biggest, widest tire.”
Even Dan Zielinski, vice president of public affairs for the Rubber Manufacturers Association in Washington, cautions buyers to think about where the rubber meets the road.
“People don’t think of the tire,” Mr. Zielinski said. “They’re all round and black, so people think they’re all the same.”
Sean Kane, founder and president of the consumer advocacy organization Safety Research and Strategies in Rehoboth, Mass., has plenty of experience with tires. He was involved in the Bridgestone/Firestone tire recalls on Ford Explorers around the turn of the millennium.
He said he faced this exact issue on a recent car buying expedition.
“When I bought a vehicle for my wife, we had to struggle to find the smallest size for that model, which were still 18-inch wheels,” Mr. Kane said.
It’s not just luxury cars: At the other end of the spectrum, when Mrs. Passenger Seat wanted to replace her Kia Soul with a 2015 model, we struggled to get the options we wanted with a tire size that I felt was appropriate. The Base model with the 16-inch wheels doesn’t offer as many accoutrements as the Plus (with 17-inch wheels) and Exclaim (18-inch) trim levels.
We decided to split the difference with a Plus. And we sprang for the dealer’s tire protection package.
Mr. Kane said low-profile tires are showing up on SUVs and minivans as well, simply for the attractiveness of the vehicle.
“I think we’re at the point where we pushed beyond what is sensible,” he said.
As for Mr. Schiller’s S550, I contacted Mercedes about the issue. The spokesman refused to go on the record.
Mr. Schiller, though, notes it’s his fourth Mercedes and he has no plan to abandon the automaker. But he’ll definitely avoid low-profile tires in future cars, which may be a challenge unless automakers start changing what they offer.
A final note: The Rubber Manufacturers Association’s Mr. Zielinski wanted to make this plug for tire maintenance: Vehicle owners should check the tire pressure every month and have the tires checked during all regular service appointments.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.