A number like $6.7 trillion is hard to ignore. That’s how much people have in retirement savings accounts and other defined contribution plans, according to the Investment Company Institute, an investment industry group.

Hedge and private equity funds and other alternative investments have yet to claim much turf in the growing market, but that could change.

Shifting responsibility for retirement saving from employers to employees means fewer employers are offering pension plans. Some are getting out of the pension business by offering lump sum payments to workers and retirees or are purchasing annuities that turn their pension liabilities over to insurance companies. Other companies have frozen benefits and are offering 401(k) plans to employees.

With their biggest market in decline, purveyors of hedge funds and other alternative investments are venturing into the more promising side of retirement saving.

Advertise with us

“It’s just a growing asset. Money keeps pouring in every paycheck,” James Zalenka, a certified financial planner with Baran James in Scott, said of 401(k) plans.

Mr. Zalenka said hedge funds and private equity, unlike mutual funds and other investments commonly found in 401(k) plans, do not provide enough information about their fees and performance to make him comfortable recommending them to clients.

“I think it’s better to have the basic asset classes covered,” he said.

However, adding new options such as alternative investments is one of nine hot trends among 401(k) plan sponsors, according to one benefits consultant.

“Consideration is being given to weightings toward alternatives, such as direct real estate, commodities, hedge funds and private equity,” Cammack Retirement Group’s Jeffrey Snyder wrote recently.

Advertise with us

Proponents say alternative investments offer retirement savers the same benefits they provide to pension funds: greater diversification and the opportunity to hedge risk.

“You can create better returns with lower levels of risk,” said Rob Cirrotti, head of retirement solutions at Pershing, a unit of BNY Mellon.

Mr. Cirrotti said the limited number of employers using alternative investments generally have more than $250 million in their 401(k) plans and are using them as part of packaged portfolios such as target date funds, that are intended to provide a one-fund solution to participants.

Target date funds are designed for workers who expect to retire near a given year. The funds shift their portfolios from riskier investments the further a person is away from retiring to more conservative ones as they approach retirement.

Using alternative investments as part of a professionally managed target date fund gives investors exposure to asset classes that can hedge risk and provide returns that are not tied to how the stock and bond markets perform, said Cammack vice president Denise Burns, head of investments for the consulting group.

Advertise with us

“There’s definitely demand and there’s definitely interest,” she said. “I’m not sure everyone has figured out the best way to do this.”

Ms. Burns expects 401(k) plans will be slow to adopt alternative investments. “The biggest obstacle is liquidity,” she said, pointing out that it’s harder to sell real estate or private equity investments than it is to sell a stock or a bond.

Benefit consultant Aon Hewitt said only 7 percent of of 401(k) plans offer specialty or sector funds as an investment option, a category that includes real assets and commodity funds. However, 36 percent of the plans say they are likely to add that category in the future.

Winfield Evans, Aon Hewitt’s director of investment strategy and solutions, said it’s not clear how fast plans will take to alternative investments. The performance of those asset classes will influence how 401(k) plans and their advisers feel about them, he said.

Offering the investments as part of a professionally managed, one-fund solution will allay concerns about unsophisticated 401(k) participants dabbling in investments that can give professionals fits. Calpers, a $300 billion California state pension plan, is unwinding a $4 billion hedge fund portfolio, citing concerns about the cost and complexity of the investments.

Advertise with us

Imagine how complex they will be for 401(k) investors who, according to investment firm Charles Schwab, typically spend more time researching where to go on vacation than they do analyzing their 401(k) investment options.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.