Pennsylvania’s new governor, Tom Wolf, has set off alarms in Harrisburg and across the state with his sweeping proposals to overhaul the state’s tax system, including an ambitious plan to raise the sales tax and broaden it to cover everything from candy at the drugstore to services at the funeral home.
But as bold as he was, the Democratic governor didn’t go after the exemption that the Keystone State has long given for purchases of clothing.
Brian Rider, president and CEO of the Pennsylvania Retailers’ Association, appreciated that. “I told him personally the day of his address, ‘Thank you for not including clothing and footwear. ’ ”
The sales tax exemption that Pennsylvanians enjoy when they pick up a new coat at Target, invest in a suit at Macy’s or outfit the kids with new shoes at Little’s in Squirrel Hill is not common across the country. Of the 44 states that have a sales tax, only seven either fully or partially exempt clothing, according to a 2012 tally by the Tax Foundation, a research group in Washington, D.C.
Some would argue that’s because such exemptions aren’t good tax policy and they force sales taxes on other goods to be higher. Retail and tourism officials counter that there’s no denying an exemption makes shoppers more willing to move their purchases into states like Pennsylvania.
“That’s a competitive advantage for us,” said Mark Jubelirer, whose family owns the Reyers Shoe Store in Sharon. The 36,000-square-foot Mercer County store, known for decades for having even hard-to-find sizes, targets customers in a market stretching from Pittsburgh up to Erie and over to Cleveland, but draws from beyond as well.
Mr. Jubelirer is hoping great customer service and selection will fend off the explosion of competition coming via the Internet, but he appreciates the extra draw of the exemption from Pennsylvania’s sales tax. “I would say it’s a big factor,” he said. “It’s 6 percent. Six percent is a big number.”
Exactly how many of the busloads of Canadians migrating south to shop at Grove City Premium Outlets or Ross Park Mall are coming because of the clothing sales tax exemption would be hard to calculate, but officials at both shopping centers are convinced it matters.
“Our retailers tell us that shoppers often choose to visit Grove City Premium Outlets over centers that may be closer to their home, which encourages world-class, name brands to continue to open at the center. This is a crucial factor in helping the state of Pennsylvania garner tourist dollars,” according to a statement from Simon Properties Group, the Indianapolis mall operator that owns both the outlet mall in Mercer County and the suburban mall in Allegheny County.
Tourism agency VisitMercerCountyPa ranks shopping as the No. 1 tourist activity in that county and estimates 20 percent of the more than 6 million people who visit the outlet mall along Interstate 79 annually come from Canada, according to Peggy Mazyck, director of the agency.
The Pennsylvania sales tax exemption gets mentioned in posts on travel site TripAdvisor.
In August, JeremyFromToronto praised Ross Park Mall, adding, “I think this Nordstrom is one of the closest locations to Toronto (others being slightly closer are Detroit and Cleveland) for Canadians looking for no sales tax on clothes and hoping to avoid duties (it’s quite easy to spend 72+ hours in Pittsburgh).”
Pennsylvania isn’t the only state known for its clothing sales tax exemption.
Mall of America — the Minnesota mall with 520 stores, 50 restaurants and 40 million visitors annually — touts its state’s clothing sales tax exemption in numerous places on its website. The mall also claims that four out of 10 visitors to the shopping center are tourists.
Two years ago, Minnesota Gov. Mark Dayton proposed what the St. Paul Pioneer Press described as the most comprehensive overhaul of the state’s tax system in decades, including expanding the sales tax to business and consumer services — and clothing. He gave up on that a couple months later in the face of intense opposition.
Connecticut’s sales tax exemption for clothing has been in play. Two years ago, Gov. Dannel P. Malloy proposed reinstating the sales tax exemption for some clothing as part of “middle class tax relief.” Last month, he offered a new budget proposal that would lower the overall sales tax to 5.95 percent over two years, but would eliminate the clothing sales tax exemption scheduled to restart on July 1.
It’s not easy changing tax rules, said John L. Mikesell, a professor at Indiana University in Bloomington, Ind., who specializes in sales and property tax policy.
He’s not surprised to see those affected by proposed shifts put up a fierce fight. “The problem is once something has escaped from the sales tax base, it’s really hard to get it back in,” said Mr. Mikesell.
He sees the clothing tax exemption as regressive, in that it hits low-income customers harder than those with higher incomes.
Despite all the signs that customers are bringing purchases to Pennsylvania as a result of the exemption, he believes the set-up just shifts costs around. Fewer exemptions would reduce compliance and administrative complexities for businesses dealing with the tax code, he said, plus allow the overall sales tax to be set lower.
“It’s probably not an economic gain to Pennsylvania,” Mr. Mikesell said.
There’s little doubt that sales tax policies affect behavior. In a 2014 piece for the Tax Foundation, Scott Drenkard noted stores may choose to locate near, but not inside, higher sales tax areas. He cited a study that showed per capita sales in border counties in New Hampshire — which doesn’t have a sales tax at all — had tripled since the late 1950s, while those in Vermont border counties were flat.
“State and local governments should be cautious about raising rates too high relative to their neighbors because doing so will amount to less revenue than expected, or in extreme cases, revenue losses despite the higher tax rate,” Mr. Drenkard wrote.
Pennsylvania’s neighbors have a mix of policies. Ohio, Maryland and West Virginia all have sales taxes on clothing. New Jersey and New York have certain exemptions, while Delaware has no sales tax.
“We do get shoppers from West Virginia and Ohio,” said Jodi Dague, general manager of the Tanger Outlets shopping center along Interstate 79 in South Strabane. She said the Washington County mall estimates about 20 percent of its visitors are from those states, drawn by the mix of stores but also not averse to avoiding paying a tax on clothes.
Mr. Rider at the Pennsylvania Retailers Association serves members who don’t benefit from the tax policy, but he recognizes its value to those who do. “Preserving that exemption on clothing and footwear is very important to a lot of our members,” he said, noting it also gives bricks-and-mortar stores something to help in the competition with online stores.
While he’s happy that Mr. Wolf steered cleared of the exemption, he is girding for a battle on another part of the governor’s proposal that would slash the funds that retailers now keep to cover the cost of collecting and administering sales tax for the state.
It’s a familiar battle. He said the last two governors, Republican Tom Corbett and Democrat Ed Rendell, both tried to do the same thing.
Teresa F. Lindeman: tlindeman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2018





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.