Mention insider trading and people immediately think of wily hedge fund managers tapping their contacts, law firm clerks tipping friends about pending mergers, or pharmaceutical researchers capitalizing on their knowledge of drug trial outcomes.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has added a group to the list of usual suspects: computer geeks.
The agency wants to punish two former Capital One Financial employees who they allege used their access to the credit card company’s massive, nonpublic database to make nearly $3 million in illegal profits.
Documents filed in federal court in Philadelphia indicate two former Capital One employees accessed the company’s database “hundreds, if not thousands, of times,” looking at sales data for at least 170 retailers that processed payments made with Capital One cards.
Based on their analysis of that information, the two employees invested in stock options shortly before retailers reported quarterly earnings.
If they thought the earnings would drive the stock higher, they purchased call options, which give the holder the right to purchase shares at a prescribed price that the former employees anticipated would be lower than where the stock would end up once earnings were announced. If they thought the earnings would disappoint investors, they bought put options, which allow the holder to sell the underlying stock at a prescribed price, presumably higher than what the price would be after the earnings announcement.
Using the nonpublic information enabled the analysts to realize profits of $2.8 million from at least November 2013 until January, according to the SEC. The agency filed its complaint Jan. 21, five days after Capital One dismissed the employees, according to the lawsuit.
The agency wants them to pay back their profits, plus interest, as well as a penalty of up to three times their profits. In the meantime, a judge has frozen some of their accounts to make sure the money for paying the sanctions will be there.
The SEC bases its case against the two former employees on what is known as the “misappropriation” theory. Unlike insider trading involving actual company insiders, misappropriation cases involve individuals who use nonpublic information to trade securities — information obtained in violation of a duty they owe to the source of the information, in this case, their employer.
According to the lawsuit, Capital One’s code of conduct prohibited buying or selling stocks “when you have material information that has not been released to the public.” It also prohibited employees from supplying that information to others who could use it to trade.
“The prohibitions in the employee handbook strengthen the case. But even without that, I think the SEC would have a strong case,” said George Meierhofer, a lawyer in the New York office of Kaufman Dolowich & Voluck.
Richard Schulman, a securities fraud attorney with Duval & Stachenfeld in New York, said the misappropriation theory was upheld in a 1997 U.S. Supreme Court decision involving a lawyer who was involved in merger negotiations and purchased options in the target company. Mr. Schulman said the same requirement not to profit from confidential information can apply to accountants.
According to Mr. Schulman and Mr. Meierhofer, the SEC most likely learned of what the credit card analysts were up to in one of two ways. Either Capital One discovered the activity and reported it to the SEC or the agency was monitoring trading activity.
Mr. Schulman said the SEC keeps tabs on trading around earnings releases and other dates where news might influence stock prices. The use of options, which allow investors to make large bets by putting relatively little money down, are another thing regulators keep an eye out for, Mr. Meierhofer said.
“Unusual options activity is always a dead giveaway,” he said.
Mr. Meierhofer believes the case could have implications for other investors who mine data looking for actionable information.
For example, a hedge fund could hire a firm to analyze databases for usable information and have no idea whether it was receiving public or nonpublic information, making it difficult for the SEC to prove whether the hedge fund acted with fraudulent intent when it traded securities using the information, he said.
“People who use these data mining services will be getting an advantage over others in the market,” Mr. Meierhofer said. “[The SEC] may have to come up with a new theory of insider trading liability to address this concern.”
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.