Battle of the little big boys: 2015 Honda Pilot SE 4WD vs. 2015 Mazda CX-9 AWD Grand Touring

This week: Mazda CX-9.

Price: $39,890 as tested (bumped up $2,435 for the GT Tech package — more on that below). A base CX-9 Sport starts at $29,985 with power to the front wheels, and $31,575 powering all four.

Marketer’s pitch: “Remarkably engineered to take on the incredible.”

Advertise with us

Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com liked the “responsive steering; strong V6 engine; spacious interior; easy-access third-row seat with room for adults,” but not the
 “middling crash-test scores; long rear doors; stiff ride with 20-inch wheels; underwhelming touchscreen interface.”

Reality: Room for the family — without forgetting the driver.

Catching up: Last week we rode in the Honda Pilot, an aging crossover set for a full redesign for the 2016 model year. But the Pilot still has its virtues, not least of which are heavy discounts.

Showing its age: Even Mazda press materials refer to the model as “the elder statesman” of the lineup. Mazda has remade much of its lineup in the last few years, but no redesign looms for the CX-9. So unlike the Pilot, discounts for the CX-9 may not apply.

On the road: Since unveiling the Miata for the 1990 model year, Mazda has made itself into the sporty Japanese automaker. Even the CX-9 meets these criteria; despite having room for seven, the crossover handles like a sports sedan.

Advertise with us

Up to speed: The 3.7-liter V-6 creates 273 horsepower, motivating the CX-9 to highway speeds without hesitation.

At a price: I usually feature fuel economy at the end, but the CX-9’s is notable. It’s pitiful, and has been in previous Driver’s Seat tests. I barely eked out 14 mpg in an initial suburban-and-country-road trip. After a few days and some highways, it came up to an average of 16 mpg, still dismal and about the worst of any vehicle in my tests.

Mazda really needs to SkyActivize this baby; those new four-cylinder engines have really improved fuel economy.

Shifty: CX-9 drivers can shift gears old school — the shift lever slides to the left, then moves forward and back to raise and lower gears. The big console makes the shifting position a tad awkward, though. Still, this is one in the CX-9 column; the Pilot doesn’t even allow drivers to select some gears, period.

Friends and stuff: For its small size and feel, the CX-9 provides fairly remarkable space at all its seats. I tested the back row and found entry and exit not uncomfortable. I sat behind nearly 6-foot Sturgis Kid 4.0 and found leg room and foot room snug but workable. Knees sit fairly high. This is not the board that Sturgis Kids 1.0 and 3.0 found brutal in the Pilot. And, like the Pilot, the middle row does adjust fore and aft to provide compromises.

Advertise with us

Seeing around: Mazda keeps the roofline of the CX-9 low by keeping all three rows on the same plane. Most crossovers sit the rear rows up a bit higher.

In the snow: I was able to get the CX-9 out in some snowy weather. The all-wheel-drive system was sure-footed and worked without calling attention to itself, and unlike the Pilot, everything is automatic.

Entertainment option: This $2,435 option for navigation and improved stereo seems dear — Toyota offers Entune with a giant navigation screen for half that. The interface looks like a bad html coders program. The tiny screen can be difficult to read. Tabs across the top are the only way to change the music source, and require two screens to list all the options. And the screen is extraordinarily small, especially for a vehicle this size.

On the bright side, the sound is excellent.

To a stop: Like the Pilot, the CX-9 also needed plenty of braking distance to get back to zero.

Advertise with us

Getting there: Dear Mazda, please cancel your contract for navigation systems with TomTom. I lost navigation more than once during testing. The graphics are also difficult to read, and street names are not provided often enough. The small LED screen could be a factor in that last part, though.

Night shift: The map lights shone much too brightly and interfered with the driver’s view into the distance. The headlights also shone a little on the dim side and made high beams too much of a necessity.

The CX-9 we tested had only interior middle lights for the middle and third row, not the corner lights most vehicles offer.

Where it’s built: Hiroshima, Japan.

How it’s built: Consumer Reports puts the CX-9 in the better-than-average category, a notch higher than the Pilot.

Advertise with us

In the end: Two mpg may not seem like a lot, but we’re talking more than 10 percent more fuel to keep the CX-9 fed than the Pilot. If Mazda would correct this condition — and offer a better screen — it would beat the CX-9 hands down.

If you need a real third row, though, it has to be the CX-9.