When it comes to weight loss, we all want a shortcut, anything easier than good old-fashioned diet and exercise, says ShopSmart, the shopping magazine from the publisher of Consumer Reports.

And thanks to medical advances, lots of tempting options are available. You may have heard about the new prescription medication Contrave, which the Food and Drug Administration approved in September. Another drug, the injectable Saxenda, was approved in December.

The problems with those drugs and other medical options is that they might not live up to the hype, and they have some scary side effects:

Supplements

Advertise with us

They don't work — and they might actually be harmful. “There's no natural herb that leads to weight loss,” said Pieter Cohen, a physician at Harvard Medical School and the Cambridge Health Alliance in Massachusetts. “And of all dietary supplements, the ones for weight loss seem to cause the most harm — sometimes liver failure and even death."

Avoid them all. Here's why:

• Supplements aren't tested for safety. They don't have to be proved effective or even safe, unlike over-the-counter drugs.

• They can cause dangerous side effects. In Consumer Reports’ survey of almost 3,000 Americans, about half of supplement users said they experienced at least one side effect — most often a faster heart rate, jitters, digestive problems or dry mouth. Even supplements that contain only plants may not be safe. For instance, yohimbe, an African tree bark extract marketed as a dietary supplement, can cause elevated blood pressure or panic attacks.

• Recalled products are still sold. The FDA has recalled hundreds of supplements that have contained drugs. In a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, researchers tested 27 easily purchased supplements out of 274 that had been recalled between 2009 and 2012. The study (which was financed in part by a grant from Consumers Union, the advocacy arm of Consumer Reports' parent company) found that two-thirds contained banned drugs.

Advertise with us

Drugs

Weight-loss medications aren’t effective and have some scary side effects. And none of them work well without lifestyle changes, including exercising and dieting.

“It's hard to be enthusiastic about weight-loss drugs,” says Steven Woloshin, a professor of medicine at the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy & Clinical Practice. Although they’re FDA-approved, many of the meds have side effects that can be life-threatening. So, yes, they can help you lose a few extra pounds, but ShopSmart asks, why take that kind of risk?

Surgery

Although surgery might improve your quality of life, the risks are serious. Death rates are less than 1 percent, but the overall complication rate is 17 percent, and the re-operation rate is 7 percent, according to a recent study review published in JAMA Surgery.

Advertise with us

Surgery might make sense if you’re obese and young because the health benefits add up over time. Most procedures require just a small incision. The newest one, endoscopic sleeve gastroplasty, doesn’t involve any incision.

The best candidates have a BMI of 40 or more, or have a BMI higher than 35 and a serious health condition, such as type 2 diabetes. The procedures have been found to improve or even resolve type 2 diabetes in 85 percent of patients and high blood pressure and cholesterol abnormalities in up to 95 percent. Medicare, Medicaid and most private insurers cover some of the surgeries, but less than half of state health plans do.

By the Editors of Consumer Reports (www.consumerreports.org)