Giant Eagle might not have picked the best year to hit the radar of the University of Michigan researchers who track consumer satisfaction.
The O’Hara grocer scored higher than Wal-Mart on the American Customer Satisfaction Index, but trailed companies like Wegmans, Trader Joe’s and Aldi on the latest check of consumer sentiment.
The entire supermarket category fell 2.6 percent from a year ago to achieve a score of 76 out of a possible 100.
Are the stores suddenly dirtier? The bananas and the Greek yogurt harder to find?
No, David VanAmburg, managing director of the index, said Tuesday. “It’s about price.”
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics calculated that food prices increased 3.4 percent in 2014, while the Consumer Price Index that includes food, energy and other household expenses rose just 0.8 percent. The year before, food prices rose 1.1 percent, the government statisticians reported.
Read More
All the coupons and weekly sales can’t make up for that much of a price increase, especially when consumers aren’t seeing wages grow significantly, according to the assessment by Claes Fornell, chairman and founder of the satisfaction index, in the official announcement of the quarterly results.
The index, which focuses on different industries each quarter, saw customer satisfaction with retailers of all sorts drop for the first time since 2010. Since unhappy shoppers are less likely to spend, that’s not a good thing for the U.S. economy.
The retail sector’s performance on the index had been improving the past three years before dipping this year 1.4 percent to a score of 76.8.
Supermarkets played a part in making customers unhappy and this year, for the first time, the index ranked players such as Giant Eagle, Texas grocer H-E-B and Idaho-based Albertsons.
“It’s really all about market share,” said Mr. VanAmburg. He said researchers decided to gather data from more customers and that meant more grocers were mentioned by enough people to produce useful data. Researchers polled more than 8,700 customers by phone or email between mid-October and mid-November.
Wegmans, a Rochester, N.Y., regional chain whose closest stores to Pittsburgh can be found in Erie and State College, tied Trader Joe’s with a chart-topping score of 85. The two chains ousted the supermarket chart’s former leader Publix, which recorded a 5 percent drop to tie with H-E-B at 82.
Whole Foods, Target and Aldi all earned 81, followed by Bi-Lo at 79 and Kroger at 78. Delhaize America (operator of Food Lion and Hannaford stores) tied with ShopRite at 77, followed by Supervalu and Safeway at 75, then Albertsons at 74.
Giant Eagle’s score of 72 gave it a tie with Ahold USA, which operates Stop & Shop and Giant stores. Wal-Mart dropped 1 percent to 71 for last place.
The grocers as a group scored well on having convenient store locations and hours. They also did well in providing brand-name goods, offering frequent sales and promotions, selling a variety of merchandise that is kept in stock, and having helpful staff.
Their lowest score came in providing a speedy checkout, although they did do slightly better on that issue than department and discount stores.
As for the rest of the retail industry, the online sector got a good score, although that might be in part because it slipped up badly a year earlier when numerous deliveries didn’t arrive in time for Christmas. This year the group that includes names such as Amazon, Netflix and eBay produced a 5.1 percent increase to a score of 82.
Every other type of retail either held steady or slipped in 2014.
Department and discount stores, as a category, hung onto their score of 77. Nordstrom held onto first place with a 4 percent gain to a score of 86. Target, a year after its big data breach, ranked behind Dillard’s and Kohl’s but still posted a 4 percent gain to score 80.
Macy’s improved its score 4 percent to 79, giving it a tie with list newcomer Dollar Tree. J.C. Penney slipped 3 percent to a score of 77, while Wal-Mart dropped 4 percent and ranked at the bottom of the list with a 68.
The specialty retail category — where disparate names such as Costco, Barnes & Noble, Lowe’s, Staples, Best Buy and Big Lots rubbed shoulders — saw its score drop 1.3 percent to 79.
Customers didn’t seem too happy with gas stations, which dropped 2.7 percent to a score of 73, but the ACSI researchers expect that could improve this year since fuel prices fell toward the end of the year.
Drugstores dropped 2.5 percent to a sector score of 77. Camp Hill, Pa.-based Rite Aid managed a 5 percent gain to tie with Target at 78.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.