2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited: Another humdrum midsized sedan?

Price: $30,580 as tested ($26,495 for a base Limited, and $21,695 for the most basic model)

Conventional wisdom: Good for a January week like this one in Pittsburgh, but not a lot of fun.

Marketer’s pitch: “Dog tested. Dog approved.” (Approved by my three dogs as well.)

Advertise with us

Reality: More fun than it first appears — and still practical.

Sedan delivery: I’ve given lots of consideration to Subarus over the year, but none ever quite fit the Sturgis Family of Fine Cars, either based on needs or price. I’ve always liked the roomy Forester crossover or the cute, versatile Impreza hatchback. But the Legacy? It just seemed to live up to its name — a paean to history, a throwback to earlier times, a boring Subaru of yore.

Pleasant surprise: But the redesigned 2015 Legacy is a brave new world. A new look keeps the Subaru touches while giving the sedan a more Camry-like appearance. It wasn’t love at first sight, but time in the driver’s seat made me change my point of view.

On the road: The first aspect I noticed was the Legacy’s supersharp handling. Though the Impreza and Forester are competent and pleasant, the Legacy has a bit of zig in its step. Take a few country-road curves in a bit of a hurry, and the fun roller-coaster feeling of a Mazda or even Volkswagen comes to life. Subaru relies on standard Active Torque Vectoring and electric power steering to create this feeling.

Up to speed: The 2.5-liter four-cylinder boxer engine creates 175 horsepower, enough to motivate the sedan in short order. It’s no rocket, but it does well. A 256-horsepower 3.6-liter V-6 is also available for people needing even more excitement.

Advertise with us

Shifty: The continuously variable transmission served the car fairly well in getting it up to speed, but the Legacy requires a bit of finesse at open throttle.

Steering wheel-mounted paddles allow for shifting in manual mode, but I find these limiting. I always want to shift out First before I finish making a turn, and with the wheel locked in the turn, the upshift paddle is all the way over there where I can’t reach it easily. Cruise control also deactivates in manual mode as well.

Sadly, this is the only transmission available on the Legacy, although the V-6’s is called a “high-torque” CVT.

Driver’s Seat: I quickly found a comfortable position and kept the seat in place during more than 500 miles of testing.

Inside: The leather seats are pretty and soft, with an upscale feel.

Advertise with us

Friends and stuff: We packed in Sturgis Kids 2.0 through 4.0 — all fully grown and taking up a fair amount of space — and a 15-mile trip around Washington, D.C., was roomy and complaint-free. Rear legroom is spacious, and while the center passenger is not too punished by the all-wheel-drive hump or a seat that’s too much like an armrest, the console does intrude into foot room.

Accessing the trunk could be a challenge. The button on the trunk lid requires just the right number of fingers for just the right amount of time, something Sturgis Kid 4.0 could never quite put his finger on. The key fob button also required a steady, just-right pressure as well. Fortunately, a dashboard button was easier.

Information, please: The dashboard was graphically advanced, showing a pair of cars in cruise control mode to represent cruise control activation and how much of a cushion was allowed behind the car ahead. The brake lights even light up on the little car icon when the brakes are pressed.

Yet, when we inadvertently failed to completely close the trunk lid one time, the dashboard simply read “door trunk/liftgate open.” Couldn’t this be narrowed down?

Play some tunes: The redesigned stereo system with 7-inch touch screen was pretty and easy to operate. A source button outside the screen would have improved functionality, but buttons for map, audio and apps help. Dials operate volume and tuning, but the tuning knob seemed not directly linked to the radio operation; sometimes one click equaled one station, other times the ratio changed.

Advertise with us

Night shift: The gauges glow in a pretty shade of blue. Overhead lighting is bright and doesn’t interfere with seeing the road. And the headlamps illuminate the road clearly.

Fuel economy: 27.5 mpg in the usual Driver’s Seat mix of highway and city driving. It was running 30 mpg on a trip to Washington, but dropped a few notches closer to home.

Where it’s built: Lafayette, Ind.

How it’s built: The Legacy gets a recommended rating from Consumer Reports and a predicted reliability rating of above average.

In the end: With all-wheel drive, comfort, performance and reliability, I think maybe Subaru has just created the perfect sedan — though a manual transmission would be the final piece in the puzzle.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com