Battle of the fast baby sedans: 2015 Audi A3 Sedan 2.0T Quattro S Tronic vs. 2015 Acura TLX
This week: 2015 Acura TLX (both in 3.5-liter SH-AWD Adv. form and 2.4-liter Tech 2WD)
Price: $45,595 and $35,920 as tested (no options on either)
Marketer’s pitch: “It’s that kind of thrill … idling impatiently at dealers now.”
Conventional wisdom: Ohh, ahh.
Reality: I got two thrills from the TLX — one good, one not-so-good.
All new: The Acura TLX was the model I waited a long time for. I loved the old TSX Wagon and liked the TL just fine, so I believed improvements in the new dual-replacement model could only make it better.
A 3.5-liter V-6 coupled with a new 9-speed transmission seemed like a great idea, but the vehicle ended up less than stellar.
Oh, ahhh: But first, the good news. When I sit down in an Acura, I tend to feel the car was designed around me. The leather feel, the adjustable seat — everything just feels right. The TLX didn’t disappoint.
Up to speed: The 3.5-liter V-6 offers drivers 290 horsepower to satisfy all their acceleration needs. But while the Audi A3 feels like a rocket, the TLX is more sedate, even in Sport mode.
A 2.4-liter four-cylinder made available to me another week was a dog in Economy mode, but it was almost as lively as the V-6 in Sport mode.
Shiftless: A gearshift lever? That’s soooo 2012. The TLX with V-6 and 9-speed comes with a series of buttons arranged in a PRNDL pattern on the console.
Unfortunately, hesitation in the transmission dampened the car’s enthusiasm, and my enthusiasm for the car. Open-throttle testing required a millisecond of patience until the car seemed fully engaged.
More disturbing, though, was a more distinct hesitation that occurred no fewer than half a dozen times, mainly on curves when the car was changing gears at low speeds.
The car has been the subject of a technical service bulletin regarding the 9-speed transmissions staying in Park. I alerted Honda, Acura’s parent company, to the trouble I experienced, and their response is that they were not able to duplicate the issue.
Too much change? Even without the hesitation, though, it seems inadvisable to go revamping gearshift levers from the standard format. The Driver’s Seat driveway involves three-point turns into the garage, and I feared a late-night slip after work would end in a damaged vehicle.
Paddle shifters are available for those who don’t think 9 speeds of shifting is too much trouble. I do.
An auto shutoff feature in the V-6 was also not as seamless as Acura might have intended; it was more in Hyundai’s hybrid territory (one of the rougher examples I’ve tested) than in Prius’ (the smoothest I’ve experienced).
Fewer cylinders, fewer gears: The TLX 2.4-liter four-cylinder’s 8-speed automatic comes with the old shift lever. It performed well without all the issues I experienced in the V-6.
On the road: Handling in the TLX is among the best I’d experienced. Where the A3 is all sportiness and stomach flutters, the Acura felt simply competent and quick while maintaining some ridiculous speeds on winding roads.
Driver’s Seat: I’ve often complained about Hondas and Acuras having too much lumbar support. The TLX finally feels like it’s designed with my spine in mind. Perfect adjustment.
Friends and stuff: Rear legroom is snug and foot room tight. Headroom is good and width is OK, but the middle seat is kind of tough. Still, Sturgis Kids 1.0, 3.0 and 4.0 made the trip out to brunch about seven miles from home while seated three across, and no punches were thrown getting there.
A giant console holds plenty of CDs.
Night shift: The map lights offer nuanced ambient light that doesn’t interfere with the driver’s view of the road.
Keeping warm: The heater controls are standard Acura issue: Buttons move up or down for the temperature control (and cute red and blue graphic clouds alert drivers to which way they’re headed), but all the other controls are inside the touch screen.
Haptic sensors (light buzzes) alert drivers when the touch screen has been pressed, but actual buttons remain my preference.
Play some tunes: The radio controls remain designed for drivers to pick their favorites. I’m old-fashioned, and when I feel like fishing for a new station, I don’t really want to automatically scan. I like to click the dial, especially in Sirius XM, where special channels often appear. In the TLX, I have to press a button on the screen to change the channel. Scrolling is available but takes awhile to get to that screen.
In any case, a tuning knob would simply make this stereo so much better.
But the steering wheel source button in all Acuras and Hondas does have a nice feature. Press the source button and the icons appear between the gauges, and allow drivers to see the choices while scrolling through.
Sound is awesome, among the best I’ve experienced.
Fuel economy: Twenty-five-and-a-half mpg in the usual Mr. Driver’s Seat suburban and highway driving. Twenty-eight in the four-cylinder version.
Where it’s built: Marysville, Ohio
How it’s built: Consumer Reports offers no reliability data on the new TLX. The old TL and TSX models were Good Bets, and scored above-average ratings for years and years, with several “excellents” mixed in.
In the end: The hesitation issues in the TLX are not enough to disqualify it. I merely bring them up because 1) they happened and 2) the more of us who are aware of them, the better the chance of diagnosing and fixing the issue.
Both the TLX and the A3 are fun vehicles, but the A3 is just a real treat. It would be my choice among the two.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.