Alcoa was the region’s best performing stock in 2014, a year that saw local stocks lag behind broad market indexes.

The Post-Gazette/Bloomberg index of 56 regional stocks fell less than 1 percent last year, with 25 of the stocks in the index gaining ground and 31 declining. By contrast, the S&P 500 rose 11.4 percent, the Dow Jones Industrial Average advanced 7.5 percent and Nasdaq jumped 13.4 percent.

Shares of Alcoa [ticker: AA] climbed 48.5 percent last year, as rising aluminum prices, long-term supply agreements with Boeing and Pratt-Whitney, and new forays into the automotive market energized the aluminum producer. Alcoa is scheduled to report fourth quarter and 2014 earnings Monday. Analysts are forecasting quarterly earnings of 25 cents per share on sales of $6 billion.

A buyout offer from a Wheeling bank made ESB Financial [ESBF] the No. 2 regional stock. Shares of the Ellwood City bank ended 2014 up 33.4 percent after WesBanco [WSBC] announced plans in October to acquire it. The cash and stock transaction, valued at $17.65 per share when it was announced, is expected to close late in the first quarter or early in the second quarter.

Advertise with us

PG graphic: Tale of the tape

(Click image for larger version)

Close behind ESB was Minnesota grocery distributor Supervalu [SVU], which supplies Shop ’n Save and Foodland stores in the region. Shares of Supervalu, which turned in the second-best performance among regional stocks in 2013, jumped 33.1 percent last year.

Rounding out the top five were Cecil-based generic drug maker Mylan [MYL], up 29.9 percent, and Columbia Gas parent NiSource [NI], up 29 percent.

Three stocks that were leaders of the pack in 2013 brought up the rear last year, including The ExOne Co. [XONE]. The North Huntingdon 3-D printing company was the top regional stock in 2013, jumping 235.9 percent. But the bubble burst in 2014. ExOne shares tumbled 72.2 percent as investors curbed their enthusiasm for 3-D printing stocks. A series of quarterly earnings disappointments at ExOne didn’t help.

Advertise with us

The only regional stock to fare worse in 2014 was Education Management Corp. [EDMC]. The Downtown for-profit educator was the third best performer in 2013, when its share price doubled. But the company saw its shares slide 98.4 percent last year. Plagued by falling enrollment and lawsuits, Education Management reported a $664 million loss for its most recent fiscal year, which ended June 30. It is restructuring its debt and last week announced another 225 layoffs.

Next up on the list of 2014’s biggest losers were chemicals and specialty wood-treatment products supplier Koppers Holdings [KOP], which fell 43.2 percent; energy producer Range Resources [RRC], off 36.6; and Latrobe tool maker Kennametal [KMT], which slid 31.3 percent.

Joining ExOne and Education Management on the swing from 2013’s biggest winners to 2014’s biggest losers was AK Steel [AKS]. After jumping 78.3 percent in 2013, shares of the West Chester, Ohio, steel producer retreated 27.6 percent last year.

Because plenty of investors have thrown money at one-year wonders, it’s good to look at performance over the long haul.

PPG Industries [PPG], the best performing regional stock on a total return basis over the last five years, turned in the eighth best performance among regional stocks in 2014, climbing 21.9 percent. Over the last five years, PPG shareholders have enjoyed annualized returns, including dividends, of 34.4 percent.

Advertise with us

Wabtec [WAB], the region’s second best performing stock over the last five years, turned in another winning performance in 2014. Shares of the Wilmerding rail industry supplier jumped 17 percent last year. Over the last five years, Wabtec has generated annualized returns, including dividends, of 33.8 percent. The stock’s annualized 10-year total return is 23.5 percent, making it the top regional stock over that period.

Other local stocks that produced generous returns over the last decade include Green Tree rail, construction and energy industry supplier L.B. Foster [FSTR], 17.8 percent annualized; software writer Ansys [ANSS] 17.7 percent annualized; and PPG, 16.2 percent annualized.

The region’s worst performing stock over the last five and 10 years was Education Management. Stockholders who held the shares over the last decade realized annualized losses of 41.1 percent.

Three metals producers were among the regional stocks that were most unkind to investors on a total return basis over the same period: AK Steel, down 7.9 percent annually; U.S. Steel [X], down 5.4 percent annually; and Alcoa, down 5 percent annually.

Len Boselovic: 412-263-1941 or lboselovic@post-gazette.com.