Today’s feature: Your ratty old car that no longer runs, or perhaps runs sporadically.
Price: Trade-in value, Kelley Blue Book.
Marketer’s pitch: Take my car, please!
Conventional wisdom: Donating cars to charity seems like a good way to help people and get an old car out of your hair.
Reality: It may be a great way to get an old car out of your hair, but the “helping people” portion can be a more difficult issue.
A good thing? So you have an old clunker sitting in the garage, in the driveway, in the yard. Advertisements and websites abound that make it sound like donating the car is easy and beneficial for your favorite charity.
Making the donation in December is certainly in keeping with the spirit of the seasons — both the season of Christmas and the season of last-minute tax write-offs.
But how much help it offers can vary.
A Google search of car donations makes it clear this is either a big business or a big help to charities, or perhaps some of both. An IRS media representative told me that agency doesn’t keep track of how many vehicles are donated or how much the deductions can lower taxpayers’ bills overall.
How the money is used: Long before I became Mr. Driver’s Seat, I donated a 10-year-old 1996 Chevrolet Lumina with 175,000 miles, which had no working air conditioning and ran poorly. I long harbored the illusion that the car was repaired and put someone in need on the road.
But few charities actually restore your car and send it on its merry way. Mostly, the cars are scrapped and a donation is made to the organization.
That’s how things go for Catholic Charities of Pittsburgh. The agency has a car donation tab directly on its website, and Bethany Shaw, director of development for the agency, said it’s been a popular idea.
The fund from car donations has increased quite a bit during Ms. Shaw’s more than 10 years with the agency — from $5,757 through this time last year to $21,569 so far this year, thanks to a push from the agency and a few valuable car donations.
The cars are valued for providing cash to Catholic Charities.
“We are able to use a third-party company so donated cars can be easily transformed into resources that benefit our clients,” Ms. Shaw said.
Giving the right gift: Catherine Friedman, a Mr. Driver’s Seat consultant — meaning a neighbor who has helped offer feedback on test cars — has a day job as executive director of Friends Association for Care and Protection of Children in southeastern Pennsylvania, and while her organization doesn’t accept car donations, she offered a good website for people to see how different charities use the money that comes their way.
Guidestar.org is free but requires registration. It aims to “gather and disseminate information about every single IRS-registered nonprofit organization,” according to its website. The information includes background on each nonprofit's “mission, legitimacy, impact, reputation, finances, programs, transparency, governance, and so much more.”
Guidestar’s senior marketing director Lindsay Nichols said the idea of donating cars can be a good one.
“I think in this kind of economy people don’t have the cash around,” Ms. Nichols said. “So people are very thoughtful about what else can I give?”
Motorists interested in donating cars can look through the website’s information on the 2 million charities registered with the IRS to find the right one for them. Washington-based Guidestar is a nonprofit itself — with about 70 employees, it’s a medium-sized nonprofit, Ms. Nichols said — and it collects, analyzes and disseminates the information for everyday people to learn about other nonprofits.
But Ms. Nichols didn’t simply promote her own website; she also directed me to the Great Nonprofits website, which she likened to “a Yelp for nonprofits,” where people can read reviews of various charities.
“No two nonprofits judge themselves the same way and there’s really no regulation,” so doing one’s own research is extremely important, Ms. Nichols said.
She encourages people to be thoughtful about the gift they’re making. Does the agency match their interests? Is it legitimate, and is it tax exempt? And does it really want a car as a donation?
How the donor benefits: The IRS allows for different rules depending on how big a deduction the taxpayer claims. Donation deduction rules have changed since the Driver’s Seat Lumina departed this mortal coil almost nine years ago.
For a car valued at $250 to $500, taxpayers need written acknowledgment from the charity, with a detailed description of the car, a statement as to whether or not the charity provided any goods or services in return for the car other than intangible religious benefits and, if so, a description and good faith estimate of the value of the goods and services; and if the charity provides solely intangible religious benefits, a statement to that effect.
According to Bankrate.com, most donors will have to value the car under $500, because the rules become more complex after that.
For a car valued from $500 to $5,000, the written acknowledgment from the charity must be timely, attached to the return and must have the VIN and gross proceeds of the sale.
People donating a car valued at more than $5,000 should pay for better advice than a newspaper columnist can offer for free.
The bottom line: Do your homework on where the car is going, and don’t expect a big tax write-off. The best advice may come from Edmunds.com features editor Carroll Lachnit, who has edited a few car donation guides for her employer as well.
“If you really want to benefit a charity and maximize your donation as a tax deduction (depending, of course, on your tax situation — do you itemize, etc.), you're better off selling your car yourself and donating the proceeds to the charity you want to help,” Ms. Lachnit said.
“Wheels,” a special advertising supplement, appears inside today’s Post-Gazette.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.