There’s no getting around the fact that Black Box [ticker: BBOX] has been one of the region’s worst performing stocks over the last decade.

Investors who purchased the shares on Halloween 2004 and held on realized annualized losses of nearly 5 percent over the next decade, including dividends paid by the Lawrence IT products and services provider. Its shares are currently trading about $1.50 above the company’s $22.66 per share book value.

However, opinions vary regarding Black Box’s prospects based on recent statements by president and CEO Michael McAndrew and one of the company’s largest shareholders.

“I’m confident Black Box is on the right path to return to its status as a growing technology leader,” Mr. McAndrew said on the company’s fiscal second-quarter earnings call Oct. 28.

Advertise with us

Brad Evans of Heartland Advisors — a Milwaukee investment firm that owns about 1.2 million, or 7.6 percent, of Black Box’s shares — is of another mind.

“The market views them as serial capital destroyers,” Mr. Evans said during a phone interview last week in which he reiterated many of the criticisms he directed at Mr. McAndrew during the call.

The sore points included a lack of accountability and what Mr. Evans views as meager ownership of shares by Black Box’s management and the board. Bloomberg data indicate insiders own about 2.6 percent of the company’s shares, roughly a third of Heartland’s stake.

“They own very little stock, and that lack of pecuniary interest has insulated board members from the pain shareholders have felt,” Mr. Evans said in the interview.

On the call, he asked Mr. McAndrew whether the lack of ownership among management and directors “creates a conflict where maybe the board is not fully exercising its fiduciary responsibilities.”

Advertise with us

“I think that is sort of way off the mark,” Mr. McAndrew responded.

Black Box declined further comment on Mr. Evans’ opinions, issuing this statement: “We engage in discussions with our investors on a regular basis and always welcome open and productive dialog with them.”

The call was occasioned by Black Box’s fiscal second-quarter results, which were below analyst estimates. Net income of $3.2 million, or 21 cents per share, was down from $5.6 million, or 35 cents per share, in the year-ago quarter. Sales increased 1 percent to $248.9 million. A big problem was a $3 million cost overrun on a fixed price IT contract with a national retailer.

There was more bad news. Black Box now expects to report operating earnings of $1.70 to $1.80 per share for the fiscal year ending March 31 versus its prior forecast of $2.07 to $2.27 per share. Mr. McAndrew pegged most of the adjustment to profit margins that won’t be what the company thought they would be.

During the call, he asked for patience, explaining the re-engineering that got underway after he was promoted to CEO in April 2013 “is not a two- or three-quarter turnaround.” Mr. McAndrew has been with Black Box for 24 years, including serving as CFO from 2002 to October 2012, when he was named president and COO.

Advertise with us

From Mr. Evans’ vantage point, Black Box generates reliable cash from its existing business but has failed to add revenue that capitalizes on new markets.

The company provides and maintains data centers, wireless networks and other information technology systems as well as products that support them. It has tried to grow through acquisitions, but the purchases have not worked out. Black Box wrote off $154 million in goodwill in its prior fiscal year after a $318 million goodwill impairment charge two fiscal years earlier.

”All the acquisitions they’ve done have basically destroyed shareholder value,” Mr. Evans said in the interview.

Black Box has also spent cash paying a 10-cent quarterly dividend as well as buying back its shares. It spent about $2 million repurchasing about 95,000 shares in the most recent quarter, an initiative Mr. Evans supports.

“To us, it’s kind of the path of least value destruction,” he said.

Advertise with us

While Mr. McAndrew is confident Black Box is headed in the right direction, Mr. Evans has doubts.

“It’s pretty clear the board does not have the skill set for a company this size,” he said. “There’s still an opportunity to unlock value for shareholders, but time is of the essence.”