It’s a good news/bad news situation for depositors at Pittsburgh-area banks.
On the upside, people looking for free checking accounts have plenty of choices. On the downside, anyone counting on a decent return on their money will surely be disappointed.
Overall, seven of the region’s top 10 banks offer free checking accounts with no minimum balance requirement and no maintenance fees, according to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s annual bank fee survey. That’s unchanged from last year and just one less institution offering free checking than two years ago.
Even among the three banks without free checking — PNC, Citizens and First Niagara — it’s fairly easy for customers to get a free account by jumping through a hoop or two.
Market leader PNC waives the fee for customers 62 and older, or for anyone who makes at least $500 in direct deposits per month.
At No. 2 Citizens and No. 5 First Niagara, it’s even easier to get a waiver. Customers need only to make one deposit per statement period in any amount, even as little as a penny.
Still, free accounts don’t earn interest. Customers who want a checking account that earns interest will have to maintain a balance at Pittsburgh’s leading banks ranging from $500 to $5,000 to avoid a monthly fee ranging from $5 to $15.
That’s where the downside comes in.

PG graphic: Banking fees
(Click image for larger version)
Interest rates have been hovering around historic lows for some time, with little improvement over the last year.
The average yield on interest-bearing checking accounts among the top 10 banks here is 0.036 percent, up a pinch from 0.027 percent last year.
The increase is hardly cause for breaking out the party poppers. It means customers with a $5,000 balance would earn about $1.80 in annual interest, up from $1.35 last year.
Customers with bigger balances that qualify for higher rates aren’t faring much better. The average return on the top-yielding deposit account including checking, savings or money market accounts, is 0.36 percent locally, up a smidgen from 0.34 percent a year earlier.
That works out to about $72 a year in interest on a $20,000 deposit, compared with about $68 last year.
Among the higher rates available locally are found at PNC, which is paying 0.8 percent on its Performance Select checking accounts that require a $5,000 balance; at Dollar Bank, whose FreeMoney savings accounts earn 1 percent on balances up to $20,000 and 0.5 percent on balances between $20,000 and $250,000; and at Huntington, which is paying 0.5 percent on its Relationship Money Market accounts that require a $25,000 balance.
For a limited time at Citizens Bank, customers who deposit at least $10,000 in new money in the bank’s Growth Savings account earn an introductory rate of 1.25 percent. The rate is guaranteed through February.
As many account holders can attest, any interest earned can quickly be wiped out if they slip up and allow their balance to go negative.
Overdraft fees average $36.05 a pop among the region’s top 10 banks, up from an average of $35.85 last year.
In addition to those per-item fees, all of the banks except for Northwest and ESB charge an additional fee that kicks in when an account remains overdrawn for a certain number of days. For example, PNC charges $7 per day starting on the fifth day that an account is in the red, up to a maximum of $98, while No. 3 FNB charges $12 every three business days with no cap.
No. 6 Huntington is unique in the region for giving customers a 24-hour grace period to get their accounts into the black before assessing any fees.
Huntington and No. 7 First Commonwealth offer free automatic transfers from savings to checking to cover a negative balance, something other banks typically charge $10 to $15 to do.
Besides keeping close tabs on balances, one easy way to dodge overdraft fees is to avoid opting in for overdraft protection.
Banks are required to get customers to sign up before activating overdraft coverage. When a customer fails to opt in, their debit card purchases are declined at the register and ATM withdrawals rejected if there isn’t enough money in the account to cover them.
Still, bypassing overdraft coverage doesn’t prevent customers from incurring fees by bouncing checks.
Until a few years ago, most big banks reordered debit card transactions and checks to process them from highest amount to lowest instead of allowing them to clear chronologically — a procedure that tended to drain an account more quickly and trigger the most overdraft fees.
A number of high profile lawsuits on behalf of consumers against major banks nationwide has curbed the much-maligned practice, especially in the case of debit card purchases.
Locally, FNB stands out as the only bank among the top 10 that not only re-sequences checks from high to low, but also continues to clear debit card transactions that way.
Among the rest of the pack, the majority of institutions process checks and debit transactions in the manner favored by consumer advocates. Those include PNC, Huntington, S&T, Northwest and ESB, which process debit transactions and checks in chronological order, and First Commonwealth, which goes a step further and reorders debit transactions from low to high.
The remainder of the banks — Citizens, Dollar and First Niagara — process debit card transactions in the order they come in, but reorder checks from high to low.
Checks are handled that way because “those payments often are for a customer’s most important bills,” Citizens’ spokesman Steven Sylven said in an email.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.