Battle of the budget-conscious babies: 2015 Honda Fit EX-L Navi vs. the 2015 Nissan Versa SV Sedan

This week: 2015 Honda Fit

Price: $21,590 as tested; no options. (A basic LX with the six-speed manual starts at $15,525.)

Marketer’s pitch: “There’s so much to Fit.”

Advertise with us

Conventional wisdom: Edmunds.com liked the “unmatched small car versatility thanks to unique rear seat design; quick acceleration; high fuel economy; spacious seating and cargo area; excellent visibility,” but not that a “sedan version isn't offered; touchscreen interface can be frustrating to use.”

Reality: Yes, there is.

New Fit on the block: The big-but-little Honda Fit comes all new for 2015. It’s the third generation from the subcompact hatchback since its inception in 2007.

The Fit keeps its “big things come in small packages” design efficiency, and the short hood made me feel like I was piloting the shortest minivan in the world. It has evolved from its wedge-like styling, though, and now comes in more of an egg shape for the new model year.

Up to speed: Acceleration is brisk, especially in Sport mode. The 130 horses generated from the 1.5-liter four-cylinder engine get the car moving.

Advertise with us

Shifty: The model I tested came with a CVT, and the paddles allowed seven choices for “gears.” (The manual is offered in lower trim levels.) The transmission was mated well to the engine and kept the car moving without hesitation or whine through all the ups and downs and fasts and slows Pennsylvania roads have to offer.

On the road: Handling is fair at best, but the Fit rides smoothly for a small car, much gentler on rough surfaces than Mrs. Passenger Seat’s 2013 Kia Soul. (The redesigned 2014 Soul has gotten much smoother, though, so a side-by-side comparison would be in order.)

Friends and stuff: This is where the tall Fit shines. Rear seat room is nice; headroom, leg room and foot room all are excellent, but passengers sit up pretty tall. Honda ballyhoos a 4.8-inch increase in foot room in the rear, and that’s definitely something to enjoy.

The 52.7 cubic feet behind the front seats is comparable to the older Kia Soul. (New Souls have grown to 61.3 cubic feet.)

Rear passengers are blessed by not being crammed against the back window. Some small cars feel like a minor read-ender would bust open everyone’s heads, but not the Fit.

Advertise with us

The center console is generous for a small vehicle.

In and out: The Fit fits perfectly for people who have trouble getting in and out of cars. Entry and exit are easy, because the Fit rests at a perfect level from the ground.

Getting into position: Drivers can ride in comfort. The Fit is too lumbary for me — like all Hondas — but I managed to find a comfy enough way to sit.

Upscale downscale: The Fit sports nice seats as tested. The interior didn’t seem cheap at all.

Tune in, turn on: The stereo infuriates. It will switch between CD, radio and other sources from a button on the steering wheel. But if you decide you want to change the station, you have to visit the LCD Screen, which is never a welcoming place. If you’re in navigation mode, you have to hit Home, then pick, for instance, XM, then beep through the stations on screen. So pick your favorites early on and stick with them.

Advertise with us

Keeping warm or cool: All heaters should be this simple. Three dials adjust the temperature, blower speed and the source of the air.

Let the sun shine in: The windowy Fit really absorbs the sun. On hot days, it heats up really fast, and then at night freezes me out.

Fuel economy: I averaged 37 mpg in a mix of highway, city and suburban driving, with a fair amount of time stuck in traffic during that mix. This is among the highest mpgs I’ve observed in the Mr. Driver’s Seat professional testing course (aka my commuting and errand running). The Fit also boasted 44 mpg on one highway trip.

Where it’s built: Celaya, Mexico

How it’s built: Consumer Reports doesn’t offer predicted reliability for the redesigned model. But the Fit has gotten nothing but above average or excellent ratings in all categories over the years.

Advertise with us

Next week: How the Fit fares against the refreshed Nissan Versa, which aims at a slightly different budget niche.

Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.