Robert Fragasso shakes his head just about every year when new clients in their 70s arrive at his door who have not taken enough money out of their retirement accounts and face a substantial IRS punishment.

“I can’t put the genie back in the bottle. I can’t talk to the IRS and make it better,” said Mr. Fragasso, CEO of Fragasso Financial Advisors, Downtown. “We tell them we need to make sure we do it right this year, but they will find themselves in a penalty situation.”

The Internal Revenue Service’s penalty for people 70½ years old who do not withdraw a required minimum amount from their retirement accounts before the annual Dec. 31 deadline is confiscation of 50 percent of what they should have withdrawn but didn’t.

That means if a person was supposed to withdraw $26,000 in a tax year and only withdrew $20,000, the IRS would levy a $3,000 penalty for the $6,000 not taken out of the retirement account.

Advertise with us

The required minimum distribution rule was put in place to make sure IRA and 401(k) account owners pay their fair share of taxes on retirement savings during their lifetime, rather than hoarding the money, delaying taxes indefinitely and leaving it to heirs.

But each year, a number of people either unknowingly miss the deadline or do not get good advice about the consequences.

Fidelity Investments, one of the largest financial services firms in the world, reported that as of Oct. 24, nearly 68 percent of the firm’s 750,000 IRA customers required to make a minimum required distribution for 2014 have yet to take the full amount from their Fidelity accounts.

The vast majority — 56 percent — of Fidelity’s customers that are required to do so have not taken any withdrawals at all from their IRAs to date this year.

“As we approach year end, we want to make sure customers take their required minimum distribution because the penalty on any missed amount is substantial,” Maura Cassidy, Fidelity’s director of retirement management in Smithfield, R.I., said. “Throughout the year, we have various communications in the form of letters, emails and articles to remind customers of their minimum required distribution obligations.”

Advertise with us

The Treasury inspector general for tax administration said in a 2010 report that 255,000 taxpayers missed the deadline in tax years 2006 and 2007, which amounted to $348 million in retirement account distributions that should have been taken but weren’t. The federal agency estimates the tax revenue lost for those two years was about $174 million.

The IRS has established a uniform lifetime table to determine what percentage of an account must be withdrawn at different ages. For instance, if the account balance is $100,000 and the account owner is 70 with a birthday before June 30, that person would need to withdraw $3,649.64.

The IRS has another distribution table for beneficiaries of retirement funds and account owners who have much younger spouses.

Eleanor Blayney, consumer advocate for the Certified Financial Planner Board in Washington, D.C., said financial advisers are not liable if a client fails to make the required withdrawals and ends up with an IRS penalty.

Most good advisers will be diligent in reminding clients of their responsibility. “But it’s really up to the individual,” Ms. Blayney said. “Some of it has to do with people’s natural failure to keep on top of their financial obligations and tasks.

Advertise with us

“We know people need advice for precisely this type of good housekeeping. I will tell you people don’t open statements. They don’t check their beneficiary designations regularly. There are many good housekeeping tasks that it appears to be human nature to neglect.”

With stock markets hitting all-time highs this year, some individuals have had a very good investment year. When returns are high, some investors may be reluctant to sell, and that also could explain why so many people have not made the minimum required withdrawals yet.

Owners of Roth IRAs do not have to make required withdrawals. They also owe no taxes on their withdrawals, because all contributions to the account already have been taxed and the interest is allowed to grow tax-free.

Mr. Fragasso said financial advisers are not required to notify clients or keep track of their withdrawals, but his firm carefully monitors required minimum distribution rules.

“Any money that we hold for clients, we make sure of the distribution,” he said. “If we know a client is turning 70½ and they are retired and they’re taking a certain amount of money out of their personal portfolio every month to live, then we calculate that minimum distribution from the retirement plan, we incorporate it in, and we take less out of the personal portfolio.

Advertise with us

“Or, we still take it out of the personal portfolio and at the end of the year we take it out of the retirement plan and backfill it into the personal portfolio and it’s considered a distribution. We try to take the onus off of the client, and make sure we have systems in place so that it’s done proactively.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.