In late May, the University of Pittsburgh inked a deal with bar exam preparation company Themis to provide its students with prep materials starting from virtually the moment they set foot on campus.
The deal — which comes with discounted prices — reflects the increasingly competitive Pennsylvania bar preparation market, as well as the schools’ heightened focus on preparing students for the ever-important test.
“We were actually quite surprised,” said Mike Sims, president of Barbri, Themis’ largest competitor.
The Dallas-based exam prep behemoth once maintained a virtual monopoly on the market for materials to help people pass their bar exams, preparing over a million students for the exam over the last half century. Now, after a steep decline in nationwide law school enrollments and new entrants into the exam preparation market, the competition has become cutthroat — just like the exam itself.
‘Bar prep, bar prep, bar prep’
Twice each year — in February and July — hundreds of aspiring attorneys sit for the bar exam at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center in Pittsburgh, the only test location in Western Pennsylvania.
Read More
Even for those destined for success, the test is no cakewalk. U.S. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, and even law school deans, have failed the exam on their first attempt.
While there is no formal limit to the number of attempts one can make, the first go-round is undoubtedly the best opportunity to pass. As the grace period on student loans comes due, studying for the test full time — as many first-time test-takers do — often becomes financially impractical.
“They’re paying back student loans and they’re paying rent, and some of them have families and mortgages and all of those kinds of things,” said Rob Wible, director of academic success and bar exam services at Pitt.
Many small- and medium-sized law firms require that applicants possess a law license, as licensed lawyers can bill at a significantly higher hourly rate than those without one. Even large firms cannot wait indefinitely.
In just the past decade, the pass rate in Pennsylvania has fallen from 77 percent to 66 percent. That means that in the roughly 10 weeks between graduation and test day, there is a virtually singular focus on studying.
“You wake up and it’s just bar prep, bar prep, bar prep,” Pitt law school graduate Kerven M. Moon said.
‘A moral obligation’
In the past decade, local law schools have funneled significantly more resources toward bar exam preparation for their students.
“We have a moral obligation to assist our students in passing the bar,” said Richard C. Gaffney Jr., director of bar studies at Duquesne University School of Law.
In 2017, Duquesne was ranked 9th in the country for bar exam preparation by National Jurist, based on a comparison of the actual pass rates of the school’s students with those predicted from median scores on the LSAT, the law school aptitude test.
In addition to hiring staff devoted to helping students pass the test, both Duquesne and Pitt now offer free supplemental exam preparation to provide students with more immediate feedback on their progress.
From nearly their first day on campus, students are inundated with reminders that passing the exam — rather than obtaining a diploma — is the ticket to a successful career in law.
But a heavy-handed approach to test preparation has its drawbacks as well, according to some students, sacrificing resources that could be devoted to teaching undervalued areas of law.
“I think one of the reasons that Duquesne has done better than Pitt the past few years is because of Duquesne’s efforts to focus on … the subjects that are on the bar exam,” said Hannah L. Baldwin, a 2017 Pitt law graduate who now works at Pittsburgh-based Babst Calland.
“But I personally am grateful that Pitt did not have those requirements.”
‘A very expensive proposition’
Despite devoting upwards of 50 hours each week toward exam prep, with lessons running the gamut from real estate contracts to constitutional law, Pitt law school graduate Kerven M. Moon is tense.
“I’ve been looking at that offer letter, and that word ‘contingent’ has been standing out a lot more lately: ‘contingent’ on passing the bar,” he said.
Yet Mr. Moon — who was hired last year by Pittsburgh firm Burns White LLC but will not begin work until after the exam — says financial stability is perhaps an even more harrowing concern than job security. And he is one of the lucky ones: his firm will pick up the tab for bar preparation, which can cost nearly $4,000.
While that price tag pales in comparison to law school tuition, it can still impose a heavy burden, leading some students to take out another loan — known as a ‘bar study’ loan — that often carries a high interest rate and requires a co-signer.
“By the time they’ve finished seven years, some of them are just kind of financially tapped,” said Mr. Wible at Pitt.
Currently, three companies maintain a grip on the Pennsylvania market for bar exam preparation.
Mr. Wible said he can only recall three students who studied for the exam without purchasing commercial prep materials in his 5-year tenure. One “barely” passed and the other two failed.
“The questions are constructed in such a way that if you didn't take a commercial prep course, you’re likely at a tremendous disadvantage in passing the bar,” Mr. Gaffney said.
The limited number of commercial exam preparation companies stems in part from Pennsylvania’s status as one of roughly a dozen states that have not adopted the “Uniform Bar Exam,” a standardized version of the test.
Certain topics are unique to the Pennsylvania test, such as employment discrimination, limiting the ability of the state’s students to use materials designed for much of the rest of the country where students can have nearly twice as many test prep options.
Currently, Pennsylvania students have three companies to choose from — Barbri, Themis, and Kaplan.
Barbri is by far the most established in the state, allowing it to command a higher price tag — nearly $4,000, compared to roughly $2,000 for its competitors.
“They’ve relied very much ... on the word of mouth of some of the more senior attorneys,” Mr. Gaffney said. “If you’re clerking at a law firm, the senior partner is going to say to you, ‘Just take Barbri because that’s what I did.’”
But the high pass rates of those using Themis in recent years has threatened Barbri’s control of the market. The partnership between Pitt and Themis is one of multiple deals the Chicago-based company has secured in recent years.

“That is where a number of people within our company and myself included think the market is going,” said Kevin Leary, Themis’s Pennsylvania coordinator.
“Schools are very educated consumers. They’re able to see two-, three-, four-, or five-year trends, and how their students are doing with us versus one of the other companies.”
Students can find ways to obtain a markdown on exam prep materials. In addition to applying for scholarships or pledging to pursue public interest law, students can become a campus representative for a bar preparation company and in return, receive free test preparation materials. Setting up a table on campus and hawking a bar prep company’s product is often required in return.
“It definitely helps because bar prep isn't cheap,” said Kristen Brosek, a Pennsylvania coordinator for Barbri who worked as a student representative at Pitt while in law school.
The exam preparation has become even more competitive due to shrinking enrollment at law schools nationwide, according to experts. Between 2010 and 2015, enrollments declined precipitously — from 52,404 to 37,056 — in part due to a paucity of well-qualified applicants.
“It's a challenge,” Mr. Sims, the Barbri president, acknowledged.
Jonah S. Berger: jberger@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.
Correction, posted June 24, 2019: The name of the president who failed the bar exam on the first attempt has been corrected.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.