Medicare has penalized UPMC Presbyterian Shadyside Hospital for five consecutive years for patient care-related problems, including such things as the number of hospital-acquired infections, bed sores and other potentially avoidable issues, a new report found.

The penalty is 1 percent of the total amount UPMC was owed by the government from 2015 through Sept. 30, 2019, for treating people who have traditional Medicare fee-for-service coverage. The full penalty amount won’t be known until the end of the federal government’s fiscal year in the fall.

UPMC Presbyterian Shadyside is one of two Pennsylvania hospitals penalized for five straight years. The other is Albert Einstein Medical Center in Philadelphia, according to an analysis by Kaiser Health News, a nonprofit news service based in Washington, D.C.

Pennsylvania hospitals seeing Medicare reimbursement cuts are among 800 hospitals nationwide affected by the ratings. Locally, Allegheny Health Network’s Allegheny General and Allegheny Valley hospitals are being sanctioned along with UPMC’s St. Margaret, Presbyterian Shadyside and Excela Health Frick hospitals.

Advertise with us

Medicare has penalized Allegheny General Hospital for four of the past five years, Allegheny Valley the last two years. St. Margaret was penalized 2017 through 2019, while Excela’s Frick Hospital was hit in 2018 and 2019, according to the Kaiser report.

Nationally, the program saves Medicare about $350 million annually.

Hospitals have protested the program as being unfair, but patient safety advocates say the Medicare penalties prod doctors to do better.

Meanwhile, trying to improve the program would likely create new problems while increasing the regulatory burden, said Harold Miller, president and CEO of Downtown-based Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform, a consulting firm.

“The problem is it’s hard to make it fairer,” he said.

Advertise with us

To determine which hospitals will be punished, Medicare scores medical centers on six quality measures, then rates them against the performance of other hospitals.

UPMC chief quality officer Tami Minnier is among the critics of the effort, which is called the Hospital Acquired Conditions Reduction Program.

She said the patients UPMC Presybyterian Shadyside hospital cared for are the “sickest of the sick” and no single number can capture the complexity of care being offered.

While UPMC Presbyterian is located in Oakland and UPMC Shadyside is in Shadyside, the two hospitals are considered a single entity administratively.

The Medicare data does not “appropriately adjust for patient complexity and socioeconomic status,” Ms. Minnier said in a prepared statement. “When considering quality ratings, we encourage our patients to talk to their trusted physicians about any concerns that they may have.”

Advertise with us

Internal data indicates that UPMC “continues to make progress in addressing hospital-acquired infections and other safety and quality issues at all of our hospitals,” Ms. Minnier said.

Page Babbit, vice president of quality analytics at AHN, welcomed the Medicare report, saying infection control at the hospital system was a priority and that recent reductions at the institution resulted from a sustained effort by doctors and administrators.

“There’s a lot of movement here and we’re seeing tremendous decreases in infections,” she said. “It’s a top priority and we are taking more than one bite out of the elephant at a time.”

For example, the number of infections related to the insertion of a catheter into a big blood vessel fell 27 percent between 2017 and 2018, she said, while post-surgery infections related to hysterectomies declined by 34 percent.

Albert Einstein officials did not return calls seeking comment.

Advertise with us

The Medicare penalties are based on hospital reports submitted monthly to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta, which include the number of serious blood infections along with a variety of other infections, bedsores, hip fractures resulting from falls and five other kinds of in-hospital injuries.

Medicare also looked at infection rates related to colon surgeries, hysterectomies, urinary tract catheters and catheters inserted into major blood vessels, which are used to administer fluids and medicine.

Part of Medicare’s determination is the number of cases of antibiotic-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, or MRSA, which claims the lives of about 20,000 people annually in the U.S., and of highly contagious Clostridium difficile, better known as C. diff, which kills about 14,000 people per year.

Hospital patients nationwide suffered a potentially avoidable injury in nine of every 100 patient stays in 2016, about 2.7 million times, according to a June report from the federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Those injuries include a bad reaction to medicine and injuries from a medical procedure, fall or infection.

The 1 percent reduction in Medicare payments for avoidable infections and infections isn’t the only way the federal government is trying to improve the quality of hospital care. Medicare has also been dinging hospitals up to 3 percent of the money owed them by Medicare when patients were re-admitted within a month of being discharged from the hospital.

Advertise with us

Dozens of Pennsylvania hospitals were penalized by Medicare for excessive readmissions for fiscal 2019, which ends Sept. 30, though most of the penalties were less than 3 percent.

AHN’s Jefferson Hospital was among the hospitals that saw readmission penalties rise in each of the five years in the period — a 1.33 percent reimbursement cut in 2019 compared with 0.72 percent in 2015, Kaiser reported.

Heritage Valley Sewickley Hospital also saw penalties increase for each of the five years for patients returning to the hospital within a month of discharge. Heritage Valley Health System officials declined to comment.

UPMC Mercy Hospital was a notable exception: Penalties for excessive readmissions have dropped since 2016 at the Uptown hospital — down to a 0.17 percent penalty in 2019 from 0.89 percent in 2016.

At Monongahela Valley Hospital, where reimbursement penalties increased over the five-year period to 1.70 percent in 2019 from 0.71 percent in 2015, president and CEO Lou Panza said Medicare’s rating system doesn’t accurately reflect the care received at the hospital.

Advertise with us

“We all know what the best practices are,” he said. “But oftentimes those readmissions are tied to social issues, not clinical issues.

In addition, Medicare doesn’t distinguish reasons for hospital readmission within a month of discharge, Mr. Panza said. So, a patient re-admitted after a mishap at a nursing home, for example, is counted as though the return trip to the hospital resulted from inadequate hospital care.

The Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform’s Mr. Miller faulted the Medicare effort for lacking goals for patient readmissions or potentially avoidable hospital conditions. To keep from getting penalized, hospitals must simply do better than their peers instead of reaching a targeted number.

Mr. Miller would also like to see the 30-day window for readmissions shortened to just seven days for a better reflection of care received at a hospital.

“Working on reducing readmissions is a good idea; penalties for readmissions are a bad idea because resources are needed to address the problem,” he said.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699