Though several lawsuits are still moving forward alleging the three biggest tuna companies worked together to inflate the price of canned tuna, one company is now off the hook for a handful of them.
Chicken of the Sea International has settled with 29 companies to resolve antitrust claims. Under the agreement, the California-based seafood company will pay an undisclosed cash settlement and work with the companies on product offerings and reduced prices, according to Christianna Reed, the tuna company’s vice president and general counsel.
The cast of companies that are party to the settlement — which includes O’Hara-based Giant Eagle, as well as Dollar Tree Distribution, Inc., Family Dollar Stores, Inc., Kmart Corp. and 99 Cents Only Stores LLC — all were working with the same law firm, noted Ms. Reed. The settlement was announced Wednesday.
“Giant Eagle is pleased to have resolved its claim against Chicken of the Sea,” Dick Roberts, a spokesman for Giant Eagle, said in an email Thursday.
“As Giant Eagle’s claims against the other tuna manufacturers remain pending, we are unfortunately unable to comment in detail on any related matters,” he noted.
Chicken of the Sea had settled with retail giant Walmart in May. Those terms also weren’t disclosed, other than to say the agreement included a cash settlement and a deal to participate in a series of programs and new product promotions in stores.
Read More
Price-fixing investigations have been ongoing for several years. The U.S. Department of Justice has been looking into allegations that the three largest tuna companies — Pittsburgh-based StarKist, Bumble Bee Foods, and Tri-Union Seafoods, which owns Chicken of the Sea — conspired to keep the price of shelf-stable seafood artificially high.
The investigation was prompted when the parent company of Chicken of the Sea, Thailand-based Thai Union Frozen, announced it would buy Bumble Bee for $1.51 billion. Plans for the deal were dropped in December 2015 after the DOJ said it had "serious concerns" the merger would harm competition.
Meanwhile, a wave of civil lawsuits were filed by retailers, grocers, wholesalers and suppliers — including Walmart, Target, Kroger and Giant Eagle. Those cases have been consolidated in U.S. District Court Southern District of California.
While a can of tuna may not break the bank for the average consumer, the stakes are high for the tuna industry.
The packaged seafood market, which also includes salmon, clams and the like, is a multi-billion dollar industry in the United States. Tuna represents about 73 percent of that market and generates about $1.7 billion in annual sales, according to court documents. But sales have been flagging in recent years.
The three big tuna players combined controlled 80 to 85 percent of the U.S. market between 2003-2015, court documents state.
“We are continuing to work through this litigation and are settling as appropriate with other plaintiffs,” Ms. Reed said.
In a statement accompanying the announcement, Ms. Reed said the company hopes the most recent settlement will “encourage any remaining litigants to put posturing aside and work with us to find pragmatic solutions that reflect the industry's challenging market realities.
“It is also an unfortunate reality that litigants who continue to pursue aggressive, unrealistic negotiation tactics are putting an iconic American Seafood brand and American jobs at risk."
The DOJ’s case
Chicken of the Sea was the first tuna producer to act as a whistle blower in the DOJ’s antitrust case. Both Bumble Bee Foods and StarKist, which is owned by South Korea-based Dongwon, have pleaded guilty to participating in the price-fixing conspiracy.
In August 2017, Bumble Bee pleaded guilty to one count of violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act and agreed to pay a $25 million fine. The fine, to be paid over a period of five years, was reduced from $136.2 million “due to Bumble Bee’s inability to pay a full criminal fine without substantially jeopardizing the continued viability of the organization,” according to court documents. The fine will jump to $81.5 million if the company is sold.
In October, StarKist pleaded guilty to a one-count felony charge and faces a fine of up to $100 million.
Three former tuna company executives were previously charged and have pleaded guilty: W. Scott Cameron, a former senior vice president of sales for Bumble Bee; Kenneth Worsham, a former senior vice president of trade marketing for Bumble Bee; and Stephen Hodge, former senior vice president of sales for StarKist.
In May, a federal grand jury indicted Christopher Lischewski, former president and CEO of Bumble Bee Foods LLC, on a one-count felony charge that he carried out the conspiracy. Mr. Lischewski stepped down from the company. He has pleaded not guilty.
Stephanie Ritenbaugh: sritenbaugh@post-gazette.com; 412-263-4910; Twitter: @StephanieRit.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.