The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has agreed to consider whether the Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination protects a man from having to tell law enforcement officials a password to his encrypted computer that he had memorized.

The justices on Wednesday agreed to hear argument in Commonwealth v. Davis, on the single first-impression issue of whether the defendant, who is facing child pornography charges, can be “compelled to disclose orally the memorized password to a computer over his invocation of privilege under the Fifth Amendment.”

The state Superior Court determined in November that the Fifth Amendment did not bar defendant Joseph J. Davis from giving law enforcement his password. That unanimous ruling upheld a decision by a judge on the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas in northeast Pennsylvania.

The appeals court pointed to the “foregone-conclusion” doctrine, which holds that the Fifth Amendment privilege can’t shield information that the police would inevitably obtain in the normal course of the investigation.

Advertise with us

“I think this issue of whether the foregone conclusion doctrine can be used to strip you of your Fifth Amendment rights is an important one because it is invoked in a wide variety of cases, involving not just passwords, but personal documents,” Welsh & Recker attorney Robert Welsh, who is representing Mr. Davis, said.

In a statement, Joe Grace, a spokesman for Attorney General Josh Shapiro, said, “While we will argue the merits of this case in court, we believe the Superior Court properly addressed these issues.”

According to Superior Court Judge Kate Ford Elliott, who wrote the intermediate appeals court decision, evidence linking Mr. Davis to the computer and statements Mr. Davis made following his arrest, including “we both know what is on [the computer],” were enough to establish that the situation fit the “foregone conclusion” exception to the Fifth Amendment.

“The record reflects that appellant’s act of disclosing the password at issue would not communicate facts of a testimonial nature to the commonwealth beyond that which he has already acknowledged to investigating agents,” Judge Elliott said, writing for a three-judge panel. “Moreover, we recognize that multiple jurisdictions have recognized that the government’s knowledge of the encrypted documents or evidence that it seeks to compel need not be exact.”

The case stems from the October 2015 search of Mr. Davis’ residence after police determined that a computer with an IP address subscribed to Mr. Davis had been used to share child pornography videos on a peer-to-peer file sharing network, according to court documents. The state attorney general’s forensic unit, however, was unable to access the contents of the computer, because it had been encrypted, and Mr. Davis refused to give law enforcement officials the password.

Advertise with us

According to court papers, while he was being transported to his arraignment, Mr. Davis refused to give an agent the password, but said the password was 64 characters long and added, “We both know what’s on there. It’s only going to hurt me.”

Mr. Davis, court papers said, argued to the Superior Court that compelling him to disclose his password was “tantamount” to forcing him to testify about the existence and location of potentially incriminating computer files, and that, because law enforcement officials admitted they did not know what was on the computer, the request did not fit the “foregone conclusion” exception.

Judge Elliott looked to case law from Massachusetts, Florida, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit and the U.S. Supreme Court, and said there was enough evidence about the contents of the computer files to meet the exception.

“The record reflects that there is a high probability that child pornography exists on said computer, given the fact that the Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General’s investigation determined that a computer with an IP address subscribed to appellant utilized a peer-to-peer file sharing network, eMule, approximately 15 times in 2015 to share videos depicting child pornography; the sole computer seized from appellant’s residence had hard-wired internet that was inaccessible via a Wi-Fi connection and contained a Windows-based version of eMule software; and as noted, appellate implied as to the nefarious contents of the computer on numerous occasions,” Judge Elliott said.

However, in their petition asking the Supreme Court to take up the case, attorneys for Mr. Davis contended that case law establishing the “foregone conclusion” exception did not apply to the situation, especially since the password was never written down and the underlying files are “prima facie contraband.” Instead, the defendant argued, the Supreme Court case law shows that a defendant can’t be compelled to disclosed facts “held in his memory.”

Advertise with us

Defense counsel Mr. Welsh said, “We contend that the doctrine is inconsistent with the Supreme Court decisions that say the Fifth Amendment protects me against the compelled disclosure of my thoughts.”

To read more articles like this, visit thelegalintelligencer.com