A woman suing a hospital over treatment that allegedly caused brain damage should be allowed to access “audit trail” information outlining which health care providers viewed her medical records and whether those records were manipulated, a Pennsylvania judge has ruled in an apparent case of first impression.
Lackawanna County Common Pleas Judge Terrence R. Nealon, ruling in Baker v. Geisinger Community Medical Center, determined that the hospital should turn over the requested metadata that shows how the plaintiff’s medical records were viewed from the start of her stay through the present litigation.
In his 12-page opinion issued April 7, Judge Nealon noted that neither the parties nor the court had been able to locate any Pennsylvania cases dealing with the discoverability of audit trails but, as a general principle, parties have the right to access their medical records.
“Other state and federal courts have found audit trails to be discoverable, and have rejected arguments that audit trails of patients’ electronic medical records are irrelevant or protected from discovery by the peer review privilege or the work product doctrine,” Judge Nealon said.
The claims being brought by plaintiff Katherine Baker stem from her treatment at the hospital in January 2015. According to Judge Nealon, Ms. Baker was admitted to Geisinger after a car accident, and she underwent a splenectomy and a partial pancreatic repair.
Ms. Baker contended that, after she was extubated and her feeding tube was removed, she was unable to swallow, vocalize “ah” or clear her throat on command. Despite those issues, she was transferred from the intensive care unit to the telemetry floor, where she was given food and medication orally, Ms. Baker alleged.
She eventually choked on the food and medication, which allegedly caused hypoxic brain injury.
Ms. Baker sued in May 2016and sought “the audit trail a/k/a/ audit log, or metadata” information tracking the access by any medical care provider from the date she was admitted to the hospital. She contended that the information was necessary to help her reconcile “many discrepancies between the medical records and the medical providers’ testimony.”
Judge Nealon noted that, along with showing who viewed what information when and whether that information was subsequently edited, audit trails can also show where the caregivers were when they wrote or viewed the records. That information, he said, can sometimes reveal that people who were not included in the medical records or disclosed as witnesses may have accessed the charts or had a role in the treatment.
Specifically, he said, the information may lead Ms. Baker to redepose a nurse who was involved with Ms. Baker’s care early on the morning that she aspirated.
“By depicting the identities of individuals who accessed the electronic medical records, the particular portions of the electronic medical records they reviewed, and the dates and times when those matters were reviewed, counsel can document what materials were reviewed by a deponent, and when they were reviewed, in anticipation of or preparation for a deposition,” Judge Nealon said. “Since the audit trail is relevant to the claims at issue and may be secured and produced without significant cost or hardship, it is discoverable under the proportionality standard governing discovery requests for electronically stored information.”
Dion Rassias of The Beasley Firm, who is representing Ms. Baker, said audit trails are frequently requested in medical malpractice cases, and Judge Nealon’s analysis of the issues was spot-on.
“The audit trail has become a very important part of medical malpractice litigation, and it’s nice to have some clear guidance on the issue,” Mr. Rassias said.
Mary Ann Martillotti of O’Brien & Ryan, who is representing the hospital, did not return a call for comment.
Max Mitchell can be contacted at 215-557-2354 or mmitchell@alm.com. Follow him on Twitter @MMitchellTLI.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.