A federal judge’s footnote on the hundreds of racist and sexist emails exchanged among judges and lawyers that rocked Pennsylvania’s criminal justice system may soon give new meaning to those messages — in state and federal appellate courts — attorneys say.
A recent decision from U.S. District Judge Gerald A. McHugh of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania granting a woman’s habeas corpus petition may spur defense attorneys to seize upon the email scandal — which earned the nickname “Porngate” — as an argument for further review of their clients’ convictions, criminal law practitioners told The Legal.
That impact may be realized even though the special investigator looking into the explicit emails said they revealed no evidence of a conspiracy among officials of law enforcement agencies and the Pennsylvania judiciary.
Judge McHugh, writing in Hill v. Wetzel, said in a footnote that part of his reasoning behind granting the petition was that two state Supreme Court justices, who eventually left the bench after admitting to viewing inappropriate materials, were on the court when the defendant was seeking final review. The defendant, Donetta Hill, who was convicted for murdering two people, had contended that her counsel was ineffective for failing to investigate her claims that her confession was coerced because detectives used racist and sexist epithets when interviewing her.
“I take judicial notice that two Pennsylvania Supreme Court justices have admitted viewing and sharing racist and sexist pornography as they reviewed Pennsylvania Supreme Court appeals, including the period of time when petitioner’s PCRA was pending,” Judge McHugh said. “The fact that two Pennsylvania Supreme Court justices recreationally viewed — on state computers and on state time — numerous depictions of graphic sexual violence with captions degrading African-Americans and endorsing abuse of women is cause for grave concern given petitioner’s background and its potential relevance to her claims for relief.”
Criminal defense attorney and former Bucks County first assistant district attorney David Zellis said that, while he has not seen the issue raised previously, the statement in the decision could be a “trailblazer.”
Read More
“It could very well be an opening of the barn door,” Mr. Zellis said. “This is exactly the point of what can go wrong in the criminal justice system when people in power are engaged in [inappropriate] conduct, whether it’s the attorney general, judges on the Court of Common Pleas, or Supreme Court justices. It just muddies the waters so badly that it’s hard to find justice.”
The justices that Judge McHugh’s comments referred to are former Justices Seamus McCaffery and J. Michael Eakin. Judge McCaffery retired in October 2014 a week after he was suspended for, among other things, sending pornographic emails. Judge Eakin was suspended in 2015 for his involvement in the email scandal, and stepped down in March. He was later fined $50,000 by the Court of Judicial Discipline for the conduct.
Judge McHugh's opinion also mentioned that former Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Judge Willis Berry had also presided over Ms. Hill’s appeal. Judge Berry was convicted on conflict of interest and theft of services charges in 2015 for running a real estate business out of his judicial chambers. Those charges were unrelated to the Porngate email scandal.
“The principles served by independent federal review have particular resonance against this backdrop,” Judge McHugh said in the footnote.
Defense attorney and former Lawrence County District Attorney Matthew T. Mangino said the language in the opinion potentially creates an obligation for attorneys to raise the issue in state court on direct appeal under the Post-Conviction Relief Act.
“It puts some affirmative duty on PCRA counsel to raise it if circumstances exist, as it did in this case,” Mr. Mangino said.
Although Mr. Mangino said the footnote “lays the foundation” for making a successful claim for review, he noted those claims would be limited to cases where racism and gender bias were raised previously and the appeals were tossed while Judge McCaffery and Judge Eakin were on the high court.
The comment regarding Judge Berry somewhat “watered down” the issue, Mr. Mangino said.
“One portion of this footnote seems to restrict it to cases where racism or sexism has been raised. The second part seems to say every judge who has a problem of conflict of interest, or corruption, then everything they do has a shadow over it. That’s a lot broader,” Mr. Mangino said. With the first issue “we’re looking at specific allegations and at a period of time when both justices were serving on the court. If you’re looking at corruption, we can go back years and years and years.”
Still, Mr. Mangino said the footnote potentially “opens the door” for bias-related claims to be raised on appeal when appropriate.
However, attorney Todd Michael Mosser, who focuses on criminal appeals, said he has not seen lawyers pressing the bias issue when seeking federal appeals, and said it is always risky to raise the claim when challenging a judge’s ruling. Claims of bias, he said, are typically not meritorious, and he warned that attorneys should still be wary of making the arguments.
“Any time you’re attacking the motive of a judge for making a particular ruling, it’s a very dicey and oftentimes improper thing to argue,” Mr. Mosser said. “I wouldn’t think about bringing something like that off the cuff. It’s probably not ethical without a really good factual basis.”
Max Mitchell can be contacted at 215-557-2354 or mmitchell@alm.com. Follow him on Twitter @MMitchellTLI. For more articles like this: www.thelegalintelligencer.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.