When Collin McHenry was applying for law school four years ago, he was under no false impression that landing a position at a top tier law firm — or even a small one for that matter — would be easy.
After graduating from Indiana University’s Maurer School of Law on a full scholarship and passing the bar on his first attempt in 2015, the Beaver resident established his own law firm and became a general practitioner.
“A lot of people when they enter law school, they are gunning for a spot at those law firms paying starting salaries of $180,000, but only the top portion of the class gets a shot at them,” said Mr. McHenry, 32, owner of McHenry Law Firm in Beaver. “I’m not making $180,000, and my wife and I are doing OK.”
Striking out on one’s own fresh out of law school is not the easiest pathway to a career in the legal profession. But graduates looking for jobs are finding the market is tighter than ever in the Pittsburgh region, and the same could be said for many other cities.
The road to a law career is not as linear as it was 10 years ago, which means some graduates could end up unemployed or underemployed. A small percent of graduates who have trouble passing the state bar exam or choose not to take it end up working in jobs where law degrees can enhance their career, but are not required.
The law schools at the University of Pittsburgh, Duquesne University and West Virginia University School of Law have responded by admitting fewer law students, with the idea that it would be unfair to keep supplying the market with graduates who have lower odds of being hired, especially in light of the average $100,000 debt often required to obtain a law degree.

PG graphic: Fewer grads finding law-related jobs
(Click image for larger version)
“The legal market for entry-level grads is absolutely tighter than in the past, and we as a law school have an obligation to adapt to those changes,” said William M. Carter, dean of the University of Pittsburgh School of Law.
The number of applications for Pitt’s school of law has remained high. The school received 1,401 applications for the fall semester of 2015, a 20 percent increase from the prior year.
While administrators expect a similar number of applicants for fall 2016, the college said that it has decreased its class size “in order to better calibrate our number of graduates to the job market for entry-level attorneys and to ensure that the quality and credentials of our graduates remained strong.”
From 2005 to 2010, the average total enrollment at Pitt’s law school was 749 students. From 2010 to 2015, that number fell to 652. Duquesne reduced its incoming class to 128 students in 2015 from 213 in 2010. West Virginia University College of Law’s first year student enrollment fell to 323 in 2015 from 411 in 2010.
“The enrollment of our incoming classes has remained relatively steady for the last four years and we think that we have found a good balance in terms of a responsible class size and maintaining the quality of our incoming students,” said Rose Ravasio, spokesperson for Duquesne University.
According to the American Bar Association’s 2015 statistics, about 53 percent of all law schools across the country reported smaller classes in 2015 compared to 2014. Total law school enrollment in 2015 was 113,900 students compared to 119,775 in 2014.
ABA records show total law school enrollment in the U.S. was steadily rising a decade ago in 2005 when law school enrollment stood at 148,169 students and peaked in 2010 at 157,298.
Still, Pitt, Duquesne and WVU all reported that their law school faculty and staff numbers have remained basically the same in 2015 as in 2010.
“Pitt law employed 45 full-time faculty members in 2010 and 45 full-time faculty members in 2015,” said Vincent Johnson, director of admissions, adding, “We are, of course, like all law schools, being careful and strategic about replacement hires.”
WVU officials said the faculty and staff at its law school has increased slightly. In 2010, its law school had 34 faculty members and 36 staff members. In 2015, there were 36 faculty members and 38 staff members.
Duquesne said it has no plans to reduce faculty or staff. The university is recruiting for three tenure-track faculty positions this fall, primarily to fill slots left open by retiring faculty.
‘Real challenge to find a job’
After graduating from Pitt’s law school in 2013 and passing the state bar examination the same year, Julia Zebley applied for several jobs that would have allowed her to practice civil law helping less privileged people, in areas such as unemployment compensation and bankruptcy.
The 29-year-old Uniontown-area native had no success going that route. She stayed busy working for her father, an attorney with a small bankruptcy practice in Uniontown. Then in 2015, a job opening became available in the public defender’s office in Pittsburgh.
She hesitated to apply for the job, worried she wouldn’t have the right background, but has grown to love her work in criminal law. “It’s pretty much what I hoped I would be doing, which is helping indigent people everyday.
“It was a real challenge to find a job,” she said. Ms. Zebley was fortunate her father has his own firm and made a place for her while she looked for other work and chipped away at her $110,000 bill for her law school education.
“I went to law school knowing I had a guaranteed job with my dad. It was never my preferred job. My dad is great, but his firm is not in the city. Still, I knew I had that safety net and those connections,” she said.
“But if someone didn’t have those things in their favor I couldn’t have recommended them to go to law school with this job market.”
American Bar Association records break down the employment data on Pitt’s law school class of 2015 after getting their diplomas — the percentage getting jobs requiring law degrees has dropped from five years earlier. The same is true for Duquesne and WVU.
At Pitt, nine months after graduation, 153 graduates, or 78 percent, of the total 196 class members gained full-time or part-time employment in jobs requiring bar exam passage or jobs where law school degrees are preferred. Meanwhile, 17 percent of the graduating class was either unemployed or their employment status was unknown.
The rest were either in professional positions where a law degree is not necessary, in non-professional jobs or pursuing graduate degrees.
By comparison, in 2010, the University of Pittsburgh graduated 207 law students. Data showed 84 percent worked in jobs that require bar passage. Nine months after graduation, 14 percent of the class was unemployed or their employment status was unknown.
Seventy-four percent of Duquesne’s graduates from the 145-member class of 2015 had jobs requiring or preferring law degrees nine months after graduation, according to ABA data. Ten percent of that year’s graduates were unemployed or their employment status was unknown.
In 2010, Duquesne had 204 graduates with 79 percent working in jobs that require bar passage. Data showed 18 percent of the class were either unemployed or their employment status was unknown, according to the ABA.
WVU graduated 125 law students in 2015, with 80 percent, working full time in jobs that require bar passage and in jobs in which a law degree is preferred. The ABA found 11 percent were unemployed or their employment status was unknown.
In 2010, WVU graduated 126 law students, 92 percent of whom were employed in jobs requiring passage of the bar exam. Five percent of the class were unemployed.
Piling up debt
The average debt incurred by graduates of WVU law students in 2015 was the lowest of the three law schools in this area at $85,063. Pitt graduates had an average $104,484 in student loan obligations. Duquesne grads had an average debt of $109,500.
While those numbers are high, they fall below the national average of $112,000 and are quite a bit lower than many other comparable law schools, including American University Washington College of Law ($160,274); Penn State Dickerson Law ($129,772); Widener University Delaware Law School ($148,496); Villanova ($110,792); Case Western ($105,854); George Washington ($136,662) and Seton Hall ($133,000).
According to U.S. News & World Report, there are 196 accredited law schools in the U.S.
The University of Pittsburgh is ranked No. 78, which is an improvement of 13 places in the past four years. WVU’s law school is ranked 97 (tied with three other schools). Duquesne is ranked No. 111, up seven spots from last year.
U.S. News, which looks at factors such as employment rates and bar passage rates in making its lists, no longer ranks law schools within four tiers. The magazine ranks the first 144 schools, then calls the rest “second tier,” which are not ranked.
Employers and potential students take law school rankings seriously. Robert Morse, chief data strategist at U.S. News said each month more than 550,000 people use the Best Law Schools rankings to research schools.
Taking a second job
Melaine Rotey, president of the Allegheny County Bar Association, said in the last five to seven years, the Pittsburgh area job market has become “increasingly saturated.” She sees the issue as a combination of many lawyers choosing to stay in the workforce longer and schools graduating too many law students.
Ms. Rotey has a son who graduated from Duquesne two years ago and spent three or four months of intense networking and sending out blind resumes before he got hired by a law firm.
She said the pitfalls for young lawyers starting their own firm straight out of school include the expense of covering their own overhead and malpractice insurance. She said law school does not always prepare lawyers for the actual nuts and bolts of practicing law and it helps to have veterans in a firm available for mentoring and guidance.
“I do see an increasing number of recent grads opening their own law firms,” she said, noting many come to the bar association for mentoring. She thinks starting a new practice is a tough thing to do.
“But if you have significant student loan debt — as many young lawyers do — you may have no other choice,” she said. “I am saddened that some lawyers find they have to work a second job or work outside the profession to support themselves and meet their daily needs.”
Ms. Rotey said lawyers needing to work second jobs is a phenomenon of the last 10 years due to the high cost of obtaining a degree.
With 6,000 lawyers who are registered members of the Allegheny County Bar Association and 1.2 million people living in Allegheny County, according to the July 2015 U.S. Census, there is an average of one lawyer for every 205 residents.
Thomas J. Smith, managing partner at K&L Gates, said the large Pittsburgh-based law firm has hired a dozen or more first-year lawyers in each of the past 10 years. The firm recently partnered with Pitt to provide an annual full scholarship for diverse law students, which includes a position as a summer associate during law school.
Mr. Smith noted K&L Gates’ summer associate class this year includes 15 law students, including two from Pitt and two from Duquesne.
Both K&L Gates and the law firm Reed Smith recently announced that they have raised starting associate salaries to $180,000 in some markets, such as New York, Washington, D.C., and Boston. Mr. Smith said that K&L Gates is at the top tier for law firm associate starting salaries in Pittsburgh, at $145,000.
‘Take a different route’
After taking a four-year break between undergrad and law school to teach literacy to elementary school students in Philadelphia, Megan Block graduated in 2014 from the University of Pittsburgh School of Law.
In her last year of law school, she worked as a clerk with Samuel J. Cordes & Associates, Downtown, a boutique employment firm representing employees in discrimination cases. The clerkship gave her an advantage when a job opening became available at the firm. She was hired full time after passing the state bar exam.
“I knew in 2011 when I decided to go to law school that the job market was getting increasingly more difficult for young lawyers. But I decided to go anyway. If you want to be a lawyer, the only way you can do that is by going to law school.”
Ms. Block said she has $100,000 in student loan debt due to her law school education. She said it would be harder for her to justify that amount if she were not actively working in the profession.
“What I tell people who talk to me about going to law school is if you want to be a lawyer, go to law school,” she said.
“But if you are interested in public policy, nonprofit or government work, take a different route, such as a master’s degree in public administration or go to the Heinz School at Carnegie Mellon University, which is great for that type of work.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.