When Reed Smith associate Jerry Dickinson approached the Neighborhood Legal Services Association in Pittsburgh with the idea of teaming up to help low-income tenants facing eviction, Dan Vitek admits he was a little hesitant.
“We take these cases so seriously, and they get complicated very quickly,” said Mr. Vitek, Neighborhood Legal Services director. “These are intense cases that are a lot of work.”
But eviction proceedings can be an intimidating process for a tenant to try to go it alone, he added, and for the nonprofit legal aid agency to have assistance from a firm the size of Reed Smith was enticing.
Neighborhood Legal Services has lost more than 22 percent of its budget over the past several years due to state funding cutbacks, and its Butler office closed at the end of 2012. Meanwhile, Reed Smith had 2014 revenue of $1.15 billion, with 1,890 lawyers in 25 offices around the world.
“I think we do a great job and have pioneered a lot of legal arguments,” Mr. Vitek said. “But when Reed Smith shows up with two associates to handle a case, it does add some gravitas.”
Mr. Dickinson has both a personal and professional background in housing rights issues. He grew up in foster homes, and has worked with with public housing and Section 8 tenants in Manhattan Housing Court, and with low-income tenants in Johannesburg, South Africa, while on a Fulbright scholarship.
“Those experiences had a profound impact on me and how I view urban poverty,” he said. “It was easy for me to latch on to this as a personal cause.”
Even though he wasn’t sure what to expect when he and Mr. Dickinson pitched the idea at Reed Smith, 25 attorneys with the firm volunteered to help and The Reed Smith Housing Rights Project, which does all its work pro bono, was born.
Since eviction cases are heard in civil court, defendants are not entitled to legal representation by a public defender as mandated in a criminal case. And, Mr. Vitek noted, someone evicted from public housing can find it almost impossible to get affordable housing anywhere else. So it can greatly reduce tenants’ stress to hear they have an attorney on their side.
“The initial phone call, when you tell people the steps that need to play out before a sheriff can come to their door, and that the landlord can’t show up with a board and a box of nails tomorrow, you can hear the sigh of relief,” Mr. Vitek said.
The team won its first case in Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas last July, representing a tenant with a two-year-old drug conviction. The tenant had gone through a rehabilitation program and kept her record clean for two years, but when the housing authority belatedly discovered the drug charge, it began eviction proceedings.
Mr. Dickinson argued in court that the housing authority’s actions amounted to trying for a second bite at the apple. The team invoked a little-used exemption that allows a judge to substitute his or her discretion for a housing authority’s decision to evict if the judge believes the eviction would result in “serious injustice,” Mr. Dickinson explained.
It also created local precedent in the Court of Common Pleas, which could have an impact on future cases, he added.
The Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh is bound by federal law to evict tenants for any drug-related crimes, communications manager Chuck Rohrer said in an email.
“We strive to be fair and accommodating to residents and applicants by allowing grievances, considering reasonable accommodations and following rules set for in the Violence Against Women Act,” Mr. Rohrer wrote in his email. “We provide more opportunity for a family to remain in housing than any private landlord and are less restrictive.”
Mr. Vitek believes the stringent nature of public housing rules is part of the problem, since policing duties end up falling to the housing providers. “They end up trying to use the concept of access to shelter as a way to change people’s behavior,” such as drug use, he said.
Jamica Barnes is a client of the partnership who says when she was served with eviction papers, she didn’t even know where the courthouse was. She faces eviction after police, responding to a loud music call, reported finding her son’s friend with drugs on him in her basement.
“They’re still fighting my case, and helping me file appeals,” she said of Reed Smith. “I don’t know what we would do without them.”
Not every case ends with a clear win for a tenant, Mr. Dickinson said. Sometimes it’s a matter of negotiating terms with a landlord to allow someone enough time to find a new place to live.
The Reed Smith Housing Rights Project is involved in three pending cases, including one scheduled for trial at the Court of Common Pleas in September.
The project will have to go on without Mr. Dickinson for a while. He was appointed as a law clerk to a federal judge in the U.S. Court of Appeals Third Circuit, and will be taking a leave from Reed Smith in October.
Mr. Vitek hopes to see the partnership remain in place while Mr. Dickinson is away. A Reed Smith spokeswoman confirmed that several of the firm’s attorneys will continue to manage the project while he is on leave.
And he plans to continue working on the project upon his return.
“This is a much larger fundamental problem,” Mr. Dickinson said. “We have low-income tenants who do not have a right to counsel. If we can, we want to play a small part in the cause that is much greater than ourselves, to tip the scales of justice for the poor and vulnerable.”
Kim Lyons: klyons@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1241. On Twitter: @SocialKimly





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.