A driver who gets in an accident while using a GPS device may be found liable for reckless indifference and subject to punitive damages -- but only if the plaintiff can prove the driver had completely diverted his or her attention away from the road, according to a Lackawanna County trial judge.

In Rockwell v. Knott, Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas Judge Terrence R. Nealon granted a motion for partial summary judgment filed by the defendant driver, Glenn Knott, and his employer, New Prime Inc., finding the plaintiffs failed to establish that Mr. Knott was looking at the GPS rather than at the road when the accident occurred.

But Judge Nealon, addressing what he called a "novel issue of apparent first impression," said a driver who is looking at a GPS device at the time of an accident could be found liable for reckless indifference under certain circumstances.

"A motorist arguably may engage in recklessly indifferent conduct, and thereby be potentially liable for punitive damages, if [s]he completely diverts his or her attention from the roadway to observe a low-positioned GPS device and nevertheless continues to travel on the roadway until [s]he collides with another vehicle," Judge Nealon said.

Advertise with us

In Rockwell, according to Judge Nealon, plaintiff Steven Rockwell's motorcycle collided with a work van driven by Mr. Knott and owned by New Prime.

Mr. Knott had stopped his vehicle in the westbound, left-hand lane of East Union Street in Wilkes-Barre, Pa., intending to make a left turn into the southbound lane of North Washington Street, Judge Nealon said.

Mr. Rockwell alleged that Mr. Knott, while stopped, had "begun fidgeting with his GPS unit, taking his eyes off of the road" and had taken his eyes off oncoming traffic "for a substantial and significant amount of time," according to Judge Nealon.

Mr. Rockwell claimed that as he rode his motorcycle through the intersection, Mr. Knott abruptly made a left-hand turn and hit him.

Mr. Knott and New Prime, however, maintained that Mr. Rockwell's motorcycle struck Mr. Knott's van, according to Judge Nealon.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rockwell filed suit in February 2012, seeking punitive damages from Mr. Knott and New Prime and alleging that Mr. Knott knew it was dangerous to operate his GPS while driving.

Mr. Rockwell also alleged that New Prime failed to either educate Mr. Knott about the dangers of using his GPS while driving or to prohibit him from doing so, according to Judge Nealon.

Mr. Knott testified during deposition that he was using a GPS application on his cellphone to find the bus station and had placed the phone in the lower center console of his van, with the screen angled toward him as he drove.

He argued in his motion for partial summary judgment that Mr. Rockwell failed to submit any evidence showing that Mr. Knott was looking down at the GPS while he made the turn.

Judge Nealon noted that punitive damages claims against motorists have traditionally only been allowed in Pennsylvania cases where the driver unreasonably ignored known or obvious risks in a manner that posed a high risk of harming others.

Advertise with us

According to Judge Nealon, Pennsylvania courts have allowed punitive damage claims in cases involving actions such as drunken driving, operating a truck with an improperly secured load caused by a broken loading rack and ignoring a stop sign in a construction zone.

Judge Nealon also noted that while no Pennsylvania appellate court has ruled on whether punitive damages claims can be brought against a driver for using an interactive wireless device at the time of an accident, several trial courts have considered the issue with regard to talking or texting on cellphones.

But using a GPS may not necessarily require a driver to completely divert his or her attention away from the road, particularly in cases where the device is mounted on a bracket on the dashboard or windshield, the judge added.