Last year, some Highmark Health employees saw their pay and benefits increase by 47%, 87%, and even more than 100%.

They were among 23 employees of the Pittsburgh-based health insurance and hospital network giant who received more than $1 million in base pay, bonuses and other compensation in 2025.

But CEO David Holmberg was not among them.

At $8.79 million, Holmberg was still the highest paid Highmark employee in 2025, according to newly released Internal Revenue Service records, but his compensation was down $922,619, or 9.49%, from the $9.71 million he received in 2024. And he wasn’t alone in seeing a pay cut last year.

Advertise with us

General counsel Carolyn Duronio’s wage and benefit package was down $272,424, or 10.1%, to $2.42 million in 2025; Dan Onorato, chief corporate affairs officer, saw his compensation drop $176,827, or 8.5%, to $1.89 million; and cardiologist and chief medical and clinical transformation officer Tony Farah’s pay declined by $210,462, or 8.4%, to $2.28 million.

Bonuses and incentives make up 70% of Holmberg’s compensation, which fell $902,422, or 12.75%, to $6.17 million in 2025 compared to 2024. His base pay of $1.75 million comprised only 20% of his pay and benefits.

But 2025 was a tough year for Highmark. The enterprise reported an operating loss of $674 million and a net loss of $175 million, despite an 11% increase in total revenue of $32.4 billion.

Hardest hit was Highmark Health Plans, the enterprise’s revenue engine, which reported an operating loss of $609 million for the year due to higher than anticipated medical and pharmacy insurance claims. Those losses have since evaporated, with $673 million in operating revenue reported for the first nine months of 2026, a gain of $884 million from a year ago.

Executive compensation at Highmark and AHN is performance-based, considering market competitiveness and other metrics, a spokeswoman said Tuesday in a statement.

Advertise with us

Not everyone at Highmark shared the pain of a tough 2025.

Compensation for CFO and treasurer Carl Daley rose 87.1% to $2.20 million from $1.18 million the year before; Karen Hanlon, who will take the reins as Highmark Health president and CEO in January, saw her pay and benefits rise 46.6% to $8.21 million from $5.60 million; and Allegheny Health Network orthopedic surgeon Edward R. Westrick received a 20% increase in total compensation to $2.57 million from $2.14 million.

Hanlon’s 2025 pay and benefits included $3.09 million in “other reportable compensation” compared to $86,525 for the same category for the previous year – an increase of nearly 36-fold.

Highmark officials were not immediately available Wednesday for comment on Hanlon’s compensation.

At the same time, bonus and incentive pay for Daley more than quadrupled to $1.07 million in 2025 from $200,000 in 2024.

Advertise with us

Two Highmark employees who left the organization in August also saw significant increases in compensation: Angela Costa, chief nurse executive at AHN, was paid $1.13 million in 2025, up 123.1% from $501,003 in 2024; and physician and executive vice president, care and continuum transitions, Vicenta Gaspar-Yoo, took home $1.43 million, up 66.5% from $865,040 received the previous year.

The IRS requires nonprofits like Highmark to disclose salaries and other compensation for top executives annually. The financials contained in the filings are unconsolidated, so they are not considered detailed financial reports.