Getting approval for a medical procedure scan or medicine has become a frustrating hurdle in health care as insurers try to ensure that every test is appropriate and that less costly alternatives have been tried first.

Delays in getting medical care have sometimes resulted, critics say.

“Across the country, physicians see firsthand the dangerous, harmful — and sometimes deadly — consequences of prior authorization,” American Medical Association President Bruce A. Scott wrote in a 2024 survey of physicians about the issue.

The AMA calls prior authorization a “blunt cost-control tactic,” and Drew Altman, CEO of San Francisco-based health policy outfit KFF, recently said it was “public enemy number one for health care consumers.”

Advertise with us

Now, Highmark has joined other insurers in creating a fast lane for doctors that allows instant pre-authorization for advanced imaging, certain surgeries and other procedures. For participating doctors, Highmark’s Gold Card program eliminates the administrative costs of clinical documentation and appeals, thereby speeding care for patients.

“It’s meaningfully changing the patient experience for people that have Highmark insurance,” said Donald Whiting, a neurosurgeon and chair of Allegheny Health Network’s Neuroscience Institute. “The patient’s experience with the payer or provider isn’t always the best and anything we can do to improve the experience is a significant changemaker.”

An insurer’s prior authorization request is an administrative headache that can take five hours per patient, he said.

“The whole idea is not to get in the way between the doctor and the patient,” said Tony Farah, chief medical and transformation officer at Highmark Health. “We believe that our model is the best one out there.”

Highmark introduced Gold Card in 2022 and last year announced that the easy pass for pre-authorization would soon be part of Downtown-based Abridge’s ambient listening capabilities, which is used in Allegheny Health Network doctors’ offices. Ambient listening translates physician-patient interactions into a medical record, saving doctors time and an administrative headache.

Advertise with us

Pre-authorization is a utilization and cost-saving feature of virtually every health insurance product — commercial, Medicaid, Obamacare, Medicare Advantage, and even traditional fee-for-service Medicare starting in six states this year.

Even though the number of prior-authorization determinations fell slightly to 1.7 from 1.8 per Medicare Advantage plan enrollees between 2023 and 2024, the reviews overall were up 43.2% to 52.8 million between 2019 and 2024, driven mostly by enrollment increases in the for-profit Medicare plans, according to KFF.

The pre-authorization reviews for Medicare Advantage plan members in 2024, for example, resulted in 4.1 million or 7.7% of the requests for coverage fully or partially denied by the insurer, up from 6.4% in 2023, according to KFF.

Highmark contracts with third-party vendor Franklin, Tenn.-based EviCore by Evernorth to determine the appropriateness of sophisticated imaging such as MRIs and CT scans and many other medical procedures and prescription drugs. EviCore is owned by health insurance giant Cigna.

EviCore advertises a 3-to-1 return on health care claim expenditures for insurers, which has led to physician complaints about prioritizing cost savings over clinical judgment. Highmark is relying less on this service by gradually bringing the review capability in-house, Dr. Farah said.

Advertise with us

Highmark-affiliated doctors can also apply for fast-track pre-authorization approval for many medical procedures, which bypasses the clinical documentation usually required. So far, nearly 25,000 doctors across Highmark’s four-state footprint have qualified for Gold Card status, with a pre-authorization approval rate of 99%, Dr. Farah said.

To qualify, doctors must have a high approval rate on previous pre-authorization requests and undergo a six-month trial period of working closely with the insurer, when they become familiar with program criteria and clinical guidelines for care, Dr. Farah said.

“It’s been very well received,” he said. “It’s faster care.”

In a notice to doctors in July, UPMC Health Plan enhanced its pre-authorization approval process for hip, knee and shoulder surgeries by reminding doctors to submit complete medical record documentation to support the medical necessity for procedures.

“Our system has been updated to confirm the submission of such information before an authorization will be provided beginning July 24, 2025,” according to the notice.

Advertise with us

Health plan officials did not return requests for comment on its pre-authorization policy.

Highmark was among more than 50 that voluntarily agreed last year to streamline and simplify pre-authorizations. The changes will benefit some 257 million Americans by reducing the number of procedures that require prior approval before payment by insurers.

The pre-authorization easy pass might also give Highmark a competitive edge in the health insurance marketplace, according to Dan Destefano, vice president of Green Tree broker Liberty Insurance Agency.

“It expedites the pre-authorization process,” he said. “It’s exciting and it’s about time.”