Hospital security measures are getting a second look as violence against health care workers rises and a shooting Saturday at a UPMC hospital in York County left two people dead and six others hurt.
UPMC Memorial Hospital near York had a “really good workplace violence prevention program,” which had been adopted at other hospitals, according to Steve C. Kaufer, president of Inter/Action Associates Inc., a security firm in Palm Springs, Calif. But hospital intensive care units, like the one where Saturday’s shootout occurred, are sometimes overlooked for danger.
“ICUs are high risk,” said Mr. Kaufer, who has more than 40 years of public safety and security experience. “Hospitals don’t understand that. But they are. Families will act out against staff.”
UPMC officials did not return a call for comment Monday.
It is still early in the investigation of the shooting, so it’s unclear how 49-year-old Diogenes Archangel-Ortiz entered the hospital’s ICU with a pistol and zip ties before taking a female staff member hostage at gunpoint. The shooting left Archangel-Ortiz and West York Borough Police Department officer Andrew Duarte, 30, dead.
Six others were injured.
Read More
York County District Attorney Tim Barker said Saturday that the gunman appeared to target hospital employees, which Mr. Kaufer said would challenge any security arrangements.
“The workplace violence prevention programs work, for the most part,” he said. “But if you have someone with a mission to injure someone, it becomes much harder to keep them out.”
Metal detectors are commonly used at hospital emergency room entrances, but they’re less common at other entrances, he said.
Still, an increasing number of Pennsylvania hospitals are installing the magnetometers, which can detect hidden guns and other weapons, according to Chris Chamberlain, vice president of emergency management at the Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania, a Harrisburg trade group, which recently surveyed members about the issue.
“A lot of them are looking at increasing their security measures,” Mr. Chamberlain said. “There’s a lot of activity underway to address workplace violence.”
Increased security measures are intended to address the rise in the number of health care worker attacks. In April 2022, a 19-year-old patient was charged by police after kicking two emergency room nurses at Independence Health System’s Greensburg hospital; in March 2023, a 43-year-old patient was charged after assaulting two nurses at Allegheny General Hospital.
One in 4 nurses face workplace violence, a rate higher than police and correctional officers, according to the American Nurses Association, a Silver Spring, Md., trade group.
More serious incidents have been reported elsewhere.
In June, 2022, a disgruntled patient entered St. Francis Hospital in Tulsa, Okla., with a pistol and semi-automatic rifle. He killed Preston Phillips, a physician the gunman blamed for his post-surgical pain, and three others.
Less than two weeks later, a nurse and a paramedic were stabbed and critically injured by a patient at a St. Louis hospital.
“Violence has just become more prevalent in the workplace,” said Tammy May, an intensive care nurse at Butler Memorial Hospital. “Health care workers have seen that for years, but it’s been escalating in recent years.”
“Violence should never be the answer,” said Ms. May, a registered nurse for 32 years. “It’s not OK. It just seems to be more acceptable these days.”
Butler Memorial’s contract with 499 unionized nurses expires in April and worker security and safety are among the top issues in negotiations, said Ms. May, who is president of the Pennsylvania Independent Nurses at Butler Hospital, the local chapter of the Pennsylvania Association of Staff Nurses and Allied Professionals.
“We’ll be seeking increased security in the building,” Ms. May said. “We should feel safe in our work environment.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.