A Baldwin nursing home is among the facilities listed in a National Labor Relations Board complaint that alleges foreign national employees were coerced into keeping their jobs under threat of legal action and thousands of dollars in settlement costs.
The 200-bed Baldwin Health Center was among the nursing homes operated by Blue Ash, Ohio-based CommuniCare Family of Companies in Ohio, Indiana, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Virginia that sought enforcement of an unlawful stay-or-pay agreement for foreign nationals, which “does not advance a legitimate business interest and instead is aimed at forcing employees to remain employed against their will,” according to the NLRB, which filed the complaint filed in its Region 9-Cincinnati, Ohio, office.
“The employer’s conduct against these workers demonstrates it is making an example out of the employees to coerce similarly situated nurses into staying,” NLRB Regional Director Eric Taylor said in a prepared statement. “This attempt to lock employees in their jobs severely interferes with their ability to exercise their labor rights and is thus unlawful.”
An NLRB hearing on the complaint was scheduled for Feb. 10.
A CommuniCare spokesman declined to comment.
In 2020, CommuniCare sponsored five foreign national workers for permanent legal status to work in the company’s nursing homes. The company promised to provide certain advancements and relocation assistance totaling $16,000, which would be forgiven on a prorated basis over three years.
The employees agreed to repay unforgiven costs if they voluntarily left their jobs or were fired and the five employees worked between one and four months before resigning over inadequate training, COVID-19 safety, understaffing and other issues, according to the NLRB. Shortly after they resigned, CommuniCare sent them each a breach of contract notice for failing to fulfill their three-year service commitment.
Four of the employees tried to repay CommuniCare, but none received a response from the company. The fifth employee successfully paid the amount due in full.
Nevertheless, CommuniCare filed lawsuits against each of the five employees in Hamilton County, Ohio, in October, seeking more than $50,000 in damages, attorney’s fees and other litigation expenses.
“Ultimately, workers should not be required to pay their employers huge sums simply because they left their jobs for safer ones, sought to report violations to the government or sought to exercise their rights under the law in some other way,” U.S. Department of Labor attorney Seema Nanda wrote in an October agency blog post.
CommuniCare describes itself as a for-profit family owned company that operates 129 nursing homes in the U.S., including ones in Baldwin, Bristol, Uniontown and Wexford in Pennsylvania. The company was started in 1984.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.