After years of fighting prosecutors and sexual assault experts for the right to sell her at-home evidence kits, Madison Campbell finally got her day in court.

The entrepreneur on Monday argued before U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon to allow her Lawrenceville-based startup, Leda Health, to continue selling the kits to organizations across the country, against the wishes of attorneys general in New York and Pennsylvania.

Both sides acknowledged systemic issues with the current evidence collection process, including that a majority of rape victims do not go to hospitals for free exams, which serve as a crucial opportunity to gather evidence and administer health care but can also be traumatic.

Ms. Campbell said her at-home kit is a solution. The state of Pennsylvania argued that several issues with the kits would prevent them from being used in trial and therefore give survivors false hope.

Advertise with us

After six hours of testimony from Ms. Campbell and three experts, Ms. Bissoon seemed sympathetic to the young founder’s personal experience and her mission.

“The product here is one that stems from a very personal story about sexual abuse and a desire to help women who have been similarly situated,” the judge said, while making it clear that she wasn’t offering a formal ruling.

Ms. Bissoon said the states should meet with Leda to “discern whether there is any sort of warning or disclaimer or language that might simply allow for this product to do what it says it can do.”

“It strikes me that what Voltaire says is true: ‘the perfect is the enemy of the good,’ ” she said.

Both sides will have three weeks to review the hearing transcript and submit facts to the court, which will decide whether to grant a preliminary injunction to allow Leda to continue marketing the early evidence kits.

Advertise with us

Smiling after the hearing, Ms. Campbell said: “Voltaire is right.”

Representatives for the Pennsylvania and New York attorneys general declined to comment.

‘She has good intentions’

In a separate lawsuit, Pennsylvania Attorney General Michelle Henry claimed that Leda’s kits violate the state’s consumer protection law, fail to meet evidence collection standards and mislead consumers.

On Monday, the team from New York argued that a warning label wasn’t enough.

“The product is inherently misleading,” Assistant Attorney General Haley Hawkins said. “These kits are meant to be used for [evidence collection] and they do not work for this purpose. No disclaimer or alteration in how they're marketed will cure this issue.”

Advertise with us

Both sides called certified sexual assault nurse examiners, also called SANE nurses, for expert testimony.

A local Pittsburgh nurse, Amanda Ringold, said the kits aren’t a satisfactory replacement for the kinds of examinations offered at hospitals. Victims might use the DNA swab incorrectly. That sample may not be acceptable in court, and their reliance on Leda’s process would divert them away from necessary health care, she said.

She acknowledged, however, that more than half of victims don’t go to the hospital for such exams.

“I think she has good intentions,” Ms. Ringold said of Ms. Campbell.

First launched as “Me Too Kits” in 2019, Ms. Campbell’s product has drawn strong opposition from several states, including Michigan and New Hampshire, which banned the over-the-counter sale of the kits in 2020. Washington banned at-home kits last year and Maryland followed suit in April.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania has not yet taken such action, but the attorney general sent Leda a cease-and-desist letter in May. The Pennsylvania Coalition to Advance Respect, a leading advocacy group for survivors previously named the Pennsylvania Coalition Against Rape, has consistently said that the kits jeopardize survivors’ chances of justice.

“Sexual assault is extremely difficult to prosecute to begin with, let alone when you're not following the proper channels,” the group’s policy director Gabriella Romeo told the Post-Gazette previously, calling the kits a defense attorney’s “best dream.”

‘Never been done before’

On Monday, Pennsylvania’s second expert witness echoed that concern.

“Victims have a hard enough time recounting what happened to them,” said Jennifer DiGiovanni, deputy district attorney for Allegheny County. “And then you're going to put the burden of chain of custody and [evidence] collection on the victim?”

Defense attorneys would challenge every step of that process, she said, which would make it much more difficult to prosecute a case.

Advertise with us

Under cross examination, Ms. DiGiovanni was asked whether it was better to have some amount of evidence, however unreliable, compared to nothing at all.

“I don't know how useful this would be,” she said. “It's never been done before.”

Leda Health has distributed about 1,500 kits, although less than a hundred of those are in the U.S., Ms. Campbell said. Most were shipped to Ukraine and Kenya. And, to date, only one has actually been tested by Leda’s partner lab in Florida, she said.

“We're aware of the one that has gone to our lab because we paid for it,” she said.

It’s unclear whether any kits have come up at trials.

Advertise with us

Leda’s work has slowed somewhat amid the controversy. The startup’s team of certified nurses — on hand to talk survivors through the collection process — hasn’t responded to calls for nearly a year, said Teresa Debitt-Lynch, a nurse and consultant from North Dakota who works on the team.

Still, the company has continued to find buyers, including two nonprofits in Indiana and “one that's in Nevada that specifically works with the unhoused community and the black community,” Ms. Campbell said. Leda previously partnered with a nonprofit in Maryland before that state’s ban.

During her direct testimony, Ms. Campbell’s lawyers asked her why she was willing to fight for her product in court.

“This company means so much to me,” she said from the witness box. “I created it because of the real need that I not only have, but I witnessed many survivors have had.

“And Pennsylvania and New York have tried to squash that,” she said.