Citing ongoing financial stress, Moody’s Ratings has downgraded Butler Health System’s bond rating into junk status, the third ratings cut by the agency in 14 months.

At the same time, Moody’s cut the revenue rating for BHS’ partner, Excela Health, by a notch to Baa3 from Baa2, while upgrading its fiscal outlook to stable from negative. Moody’s credited Excela’s outlook upgrade to management’s “performance improvement plans,” which the agency said would stabilize liquidity.

Butler Health System merged with Excela Health in January 2023 to form the five-hospital Independence Health System. Financials for each system are booked separately, but Excela has limited ability to help BHS financially, even though management of the two entities has been integrated, Moody’s said.

IHS reported a combined operational loss of $71.4 million for its first year as a single entity.

Advertise with us

Moody’s rating cut to Ba1 from Baa3 means BHS bonds are speculative for investors, with a higher risk of default than market grade bonds. Butler’s downgrade continues a slide that began in February 2023 as management struggles with turnaround plans.

“The downgrade of the issuer and revenue ratings to Ba1 reflects Butler Health’s ongoing financial stress and operating cash flow losses, resulting in continued cash burn and continued covenant breaches and debt acceleration risk,” Moody’s wrote. “While Butler’s patient volumes are improving, labor expenses continue to drive still weak results.”

Read More

BHS’ outlook remained negative due to ongoing risk of debt acceleration and further declines in liquidity given cash flow problems, according to Moody’s.

Among the challenges IHS faces, according to Moody’s, was “ongoing encroachment from larger more tertiary Pittsburgh-based providers,” namely Allegheny Health Network and UPMC, both of which have been siphoning away patients from IHS’ primary service area with new hospitals, doctor’s offices and clinics. In June, BHS also faces the possibility of breaching its master trust indenture debt service agreement for the second consecutive year while the system has continued to breach its quarterly debt service coverage test for its bank debt, Moody’s said.

BHS has about $120 million in long-term debt, which included a $15 million loan from Charlotte, N.C.-based Truist Bank. Failure to meet any of the loan covenants would trigger a default and immediate acceleration of debt at the bank’s discretion.

Advertise with us

Failure to generate positive cash flow in 2025 could trigger another bond rating downgrade, Moody’s said.

By comparison, Excela had “good headroom to all of its financial covenants,” while management has “implemented a number of initiatives, which have helped generate savings and improved results,” Moody’s said. Further weakening of BHS’ debt profile, which could create potential spillover effects at Excela, could result in a rating downgrade.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com