The dramatic legal battle that ensnared a top UPMC surgeon and led to heated court battles between teams of lawyers and sometimes even the judge himself ended quietly this month with a pair of settlements filed in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
The agreements close one of the most contentious chapters in UPMC’s recent history — a case that began with a malpractice lawsuit filed by an Aliquippa couple against the health care giant that included accusations of mismanagement and prescription drug use by leading surgeon Dr. James Luketich.
The case would expand into a battle between the surgeon and his former colleagues over the secret recording of a conversation that took place in an observation room at UPMC’s flagship hospital, UPMC Presbyterian, in 2018.
The details of that recording, published by the Post-Gazette after reporters obtained a copy last year, would expose the inner workings of the hospital and the people behind some of its most consequential decisions.
The tape and transcript — both concealed from the public by the court — dominated the hearings for nearly two years, leading to fiery courtroom exchanges between lawyers over whether the recordings could be used as evidence.
Common Pleas Judge Philip Ignelzi at one point went so far as to threaten journalists with criminal charges if they obtained a copy of the tape or its transcript and reported on it before he ruled whether the recording violated the state’s wiretap law.
Now, five years after the case was filed, attorneys for both sides declined to comment about the settlement, the terms of which are confidential. Paul Fedorka, who joined his wife, Bernadette, in the malpractice suit, referred all questions to their attorney.
The Post-Gazette’s disclosures of the recording, which included racially charged remarks by Dr. Luketich about a Black surgical resident and accusations that doctors at UPMC were under pressure to perform more surgeries to boost profits, would ultimately prompt Judge Ignelzi to release the tape.
But the judge’s decisions to exclude the public from the courtroom in the first place and to keep the evidence concealed for more than a year created troubling questions for legal experts, who say such proceedings need to stay open.
“It’s critically important that the public be able to see the justice system operating the same for everyone,” said Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association. “We all have to live under the law and we all need to know it’s being applied to everyone in the same way or it erodes public trust and confidence in the justice system.”
The events that turned the 2018 malpractice case into a legal battle over the secret tape began after Dr. Luketich filed claims against two former fellow doctors and accused them of surreptitiously recording his conversation.
The senior surgeon said Dr. Jonathan D’Cunha and Dr. Lara Schaheen illegally taped his meeting with another doctor in a surgical observation room as they discussed Dr. Luketich’s prescription for suboxone, as well as a host of other topics.
The three physicians had been close colleagues — Dr. Luketich took the stand in the malpractice trial wearing a tie that he said had been a gift from Dr. D’Cunha — but they clashed over an alleged affair between Drs. D’Cunha and Schaheen and allegations that Dr. Luketich was carrying out surgeries while under the influence of drugs.
In 2019, the feud escalated after Dr. D’Cunha filed a federal whistleblower complaint that would lead to a sweeping Department of Justice investigation of Dr. Luketich and UPMC’s billing and surgical practices, a case that led to a $8.5 million settlement last year.
Initially, the allegations about Dr. Luketich’s suboxone use were part of the whistleblower case but were later dropped. In Ms. Fedorka’s case, the allegations would become central to her claim that he was impaired by the drug when he made decisions that took critical resources from the lung transplant program before her surgery.
While Dr. Luketich, who did not take part in her operation, fought to keep the tape from being used in open court, testimony revealed that a copy of the recording had been sent anonymously to the West Virginia University Health System, which has ties to UPMC.
While the record was under seal in Allegheny County, the Post-Gazette pushed a public records request with the West Virginia system and obtained a copy of the transcript of the tape.
In the course of the talk between the two doctors, Dr. Luketich made remarks about the Black surgical resident, calling him “uppity” and “entitled,” while the other doctor, David Wilson, went on to accuse then-UPMC CEO Jeffrey Romoff of pressuring hospital leaders to perform more transplants because they were so profitable, the transcript said.
Weeks after the Post-Gazette published the transcript in May, UPMC confirmed that Dr. Luketich would step down from his post as its top cardiovascular doctor, though he would continue on as a surgeon and researcher.
In his ruling to release the tape in July, the judge likened the internal drama behind the lengthy court fight to everything from a Wagner opera, to a Shakespeare play, to daytime television.
“The court notes this case could easily be mistaken for a script from the sixty-year current long-running television melodrama, General Hospital,” the judge wrote.
By December, Dr. Luketich and three other UPMC physicians were dropped from the case. Court filings on Jan. 5 show that Dr. Luketich’s claims against Drs. D’Cunha and Schaheen and the Fedorkas’ malpractice case both were settled.
For legal experts, the long battle over transparency in the case underscores the larger continuing fight across the country for more openness in how judges make decisions, said Seth Wayne, senior counsel at the Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection at the Georgetown University Law Center.
“The public demand to see what courts are doing is only growing," Mr. Wayne said.
Ms. Melewsky said that most legal proceedings, especially the review of evidence that’s critical to a case, should take place in the open to help ensure that justice prevails.
“The presumption is this information is public so the court can be accountable for the decisions it makes,” Ms. Melewsky said.
“We can't really understand a court’s decision if we don't know what it’s based on.”
Mike Wereschagin: mwereschagin@post-gazette.com; @wrschgn






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.