At a new surgical clinic in Monroeville — the first of its kind in the region — Allegheny Health Network is reducing the cost of care for both insurers and patients by using medical advancements to move joint replacement operations out of the hospital.

And that includes its own Forbes Hospital, just two miles away from the new clinic.

Along the way, the health system could disrupt the Pittsburgh market for these medical procedures that are increasingly in demand as the population ages and patients’ work to stay active in later years of life.

“Operations that used to take two to three hours now take a fraction of that,” said Michael Levine, an AHN orthopedic surgeon who has been practicing medicine for 36 years. “We’re just better at it.”

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh-based health care system will receive lower reimbursement for procedures done at its new clinic compared to its nearby hospital, but it’s betting on volume — the idea that offering patients lower cost procedures in a comfortable setting will draw more of those people to its doors.

More than 1.2 million hip and knee replacements are performed annually in the U.S., making them among the most common surgical procedures and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says that more than seven million American adults have had hip or knee replacement operations.

They’re expensive, too, sometimes costing more than $10,000.

Moreover, the number of people needing the operations is expected to grow steadily over the next decade due. Around the country, an increasing number of those surgeries are being done outside hospitals, where studies have shown they can be done with fewer complications and at a lower cost.

Pittsburgh-area hospitals have been sending patients home the same day of hip and knee replacement operations for several years, thanks to better pain control options and muscle-sparing surgical techniques. What’s different at the new AHN Monroeville Surgery Center is that it’s not part of a hospital, but rather a separately licensed ambulatory surgery center.

Advertise with us

That pushes down the price tag.

“What drives everything is economics,” said surgeon Patrick DeMeo, chair of the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery at AHN. “The surgery center is much cheaper to operate because it doesn’t have the overhead of the hospital.”

Insurers pay AHN about 40% less for a joint replacement operation at the surgery center when compared to a hospital, he said, but the cost of running a surgery less is also much less than covering overhead at a hospital.

A 2020 study by UnitedHealth Group’s Surgical Care Affiliates found that routine joint replacements for privately insured individuals at surgery centers cost 20% or $6,700 less for hips when compared to hospital inpatient costs and 17% or $5,700 less for knees.

Moving the operations out of the hospital has also been shown to improve the quality of care.

Advertise with us

The number of hospitalized patients who develop an infection after an operation ranges between 3% and 4%, according to UnitedHealth Group, which compares to an infection rate of 1% to 2.5% for patients undergoing joint replacement surgery at a freestanding surgical center.

Studies have shown that’s partly due to doctors and nurses focusing on doing a limited number of medical procedures and improving their performance over time.

Through its affiliate, UnitedHealth runs more than 230 ambulatory surgery centers in the U.S. where more than 1 million operations are performed, including joint replacements.

Not every patient is a candidate for an outpatient procedure, but Michael J. Patterson, president and CEO of Mississippi Valley Surgery Center in Davenport, Iowa, an ambulatory surgery center where doctors began doing joint replacement operations in 2006, thinks a lot should consider it. “It costs less and our quality numbers are quite amazing compared to what you might see at a hospital.”

Patients at higher risk of complications are still referred to a hospital for an inpatient stay.

Advertise with us

The financial equation for the different joint replacement operations varies by location. Medicare’s reimbursement for a total knee replacement in 2020, for example, was $12,756 for a hospital inpatient; $11,901 for a hospital outpatient; and $8,610 for an ambulatory surgery center, not counting geographic adjustments.

In the case of the new Monroeville center for AHN and its corporate parent Highmark, the calculation is that the shift will mean lower overall health care costs, which can translate into lower out-of-pocket expenses for the patient, depending on insurance coverage.

Highmark’s bet is that lower cost, quality care outside a hospital will increase patient volume since price and quality often guide consumers in health care decisions.

In 2020 and 2021, Medicare began paying for knee and hip replacement operations respectively at surgery centers. Commercial insurers have covered those for years. The payments from Medicare, the biggest purchaser of health care services in the U.S., is helping drive the growing demand for freestanding clinics.

Retired accountant Jeffrey Walos, 67, was home from hip replacement surgery Dec. 22 at the AHN center in less than six hours.

Advertise with us

“It’s not a hospital atmosphere there, that’s the biggest thing,” said Mr. Walos, who lives in Elizabeth Township and had his right hip joint replaced with a synthetic implant by Dr. Levine. “That’s the biggest thing. You feel very at ease. I was back to the gym in four weeks. I’m good to go.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com