Highmark Health is opening a 78-acre athletic and outpatient medical center to the public in Coraopolis on Monday, three years after rival UPMC and Robert Morris University opened a similar sports complex 5 miles away.
It’s a familiar pattern: In Pittsburgh’s highly competitive health care arena, siting hospitals, labs, doctors’ offices — and now athletic facilities — near competitors has become a way to attract patients in a market where the population has been virtually flat or declining.
Health care executives from the two rivals have said torrid competition between Highmark and UPMC holds down prices for consumers, but some experts in the field challenge that argument. In markets without enough competition, consumers are often on the hook for the cost of duplicating medical services, according to Lawton Robert Burns, professor of health care management at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School.
“It’s very simple: hospitals push the higher costs onto insurers and the insurers pass the higher costs along to employers and employers pass the higher costs along to all the small fry like you and me,” he said.
Consumers win in the strategy through expanded access to medical care, observers note.
But the advantages of competition in medicine generally don’t work in a market dominated by only two competitors, said Mark Pauly, senior fellow at the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics at the University of Pennsylvania. Three or more health care providers in a market are needed for pricing competition to hold down costs.
Read More
“It’s coming out of your wages,” he said. “Citizens pay for it either through higher taxes or higher health insurance premiums.”
“Is it a good thing? Mostly no,” he said.
In the Pittsburgh region, health care providers are competing for a piece of a shrinking pie.
Allegheny County’s population fell by 10,627 or 0.9% between 2020 and 2021, according to the University of Pittsburgh’s Center for Social and Urban Research. Of the seven counties in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area, only Washington gained population — 313, or 0.1% — during the period.
At the ribbon cutting Wednesday, hospital officials and others pointed to the community benefits of the AHN Montour Health + Sports Medicine Center, which has three soccer and multipurpose fields, including one for year-round use. Seven other outdoor fields are under construction.
“This facility is going to be second to none and it will provide terrific benefits to our organizations, the Coraopolis community and athletes from all around the region,” Tuffy Shallenberger, project developer and Pittsburgh Riverhounds owner, said in a prepared statement.
Highmark Health’s Allegheny Health Network and the Pittsburgh Riverhounds Soccer Club are partners in the project, where AHN’s orthopedic and sports medicine doctors will treat athletes at a 20,000-square-foot facility that will also offer primary and pediatric medical care, lab services and diagnostic imaging.
In addition to medical care, the complex will serve as a practice site for the Pittsburgh Riverhounds and home for the Riverhounds Development Academy, which annually trains more than 5,000 athletes ranging from 4 to 18 years old.
AHN announced the Montour project in July 2019, three months after the UPMC Events Center opened at Robert Morris University nearby in Moon. In that deal, UPMC became the provider for RMU sports medicine, student wellness services and employee health insurance through UPMC Health Plan.
The leapfrog pattern of development has played out throughout the Pittsburgh area between the rival health care giants: In recent years, Highmark opened two hospitals in the North Hills, both less than 5 miles from two UPMC hospitals; UPMC East Hospital in Monroeville was built a mile from AHN’s Forbes Hospital; and AHN’s Harmar Neighborhood Hospital was the farthest apart at 5 miles from UPMC St. Margaret Memorial Hospital.
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.